|
|
 Don't Wanna Make This Awkward
Posts: 3106
   Location: Texas | So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections? | |
| | |
 Reaching for the stars....
Posts: 12708
     
| Previcox, bute, any other nsaid. There are herbals to supplement with, and other oral supplements. Devils claw is the herbal I can think of right off the bat, and most other supplements don't work much because of molecular size. There is injectibles (not into the joint, im or iv) but not sure which would help for arthritis, Legend and Adequan.
If expense is the only thing stopping one from getting injections - you will spend more in supplements and bad runs than just getting the injection done. The time it takes to figure out if something is working or not, plus the runs that prove it is expensive. 3 months is minimum to give any protocol a chance. Only the nsaid's are going to work, period, right then. | |
| | |
The Advice Guru
Posts: 6419
     
| outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM
So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections?
Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion?
Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high.
Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states.
| |
| | |
 I Prefer to Live in Fantasy Land
Posts: 64864
                    Location: In the Hills of Texas | I'm not against injections when they are needed. I'm against people giving their horses injections with out making sure what the problem is.
I had a horse blowing off of barrels and what he needed was an adjustment and massage body work.
Drives me nuts when people are injecting joints and calling it maintenance on young horses. JMO
I do know from personal experience, how well the joint injections can relive pain.
| |
| | |
 Don't Wanna Make This Awkward
Posts: 3106
   Location: Texas | cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections? Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion? Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high. Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states.
Im just being hypothetical. If that was my case I would inject.
I just know there are people out there who simply refuse to inject for whatever reason and I was just curious how they handled a situation like that. | |
| | |
  Warmblood with Wings
Posts: 27846
           Location: Florida.. | Nevertooold - 2015-10-19 8:10 PM I'm not against injections when they are needed. I'm against people giving their horses injections with out making sure what the problem is.
I had a horse blowing off of barrels and what he needed was an adjustment and massage body work.
Drives me nuts when people are injecting joints and calling it maintenance on young horses. JMO
I do know from personal experience, how well the joint injections can relive pain.
 ditto | |
| | |
 A Somebody to Everybody
Posts: 41354
              Location: Under The Big Sky Of Texas | Bibliafarm - 2015-10-19 8:17 PM Nevertooold - 2015-10-19 8:10 PM I'm not against injections when they are needed. I'm against people giving their horses injections with out making sure what the problem is.
I had a horse blowing off of barrels and what he needed was an adjustment and massage body work.
Drives me nuts when people are injecting joints and calling it maintenance on young horses. JMO
I do know from personal experience, how well the joint injections can relive pain.
  ditto
Double Ditto | |
| | |
 Owner of a ratting catting machine
Posts: 2258
    
| cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM
outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM
So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections?
Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion?
Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high.
Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states.
Dr Honnas doesn't do them. He refers them to Dr Hague in Edmond, Ok. I am currently 14 months out and waiting for soundness to return to one that I had fused. I don't regret doing it, I didn't have a horse either way, and he should eventually come sound again. Hypothetically and optimistically, best case scenario. But it isn't always a peaches and cream surgery. Everyone needs to go into that with their eyes open, for sure. | |
| | |
Elite Veteran
Posts: 1131
  
| outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 8:53 PM
cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections? Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion? Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high. Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states.
Im just being hypothetical. If that was my case I would inject.
I just know there are people out there who simply refuse to inject for whatever reason and I was just curious how they handled a situation like that.
Here's how I see it. This is blunt honesty, take it for what it is - my opinion.
If you won't inject after 3 vets tell you they need it but just try to go the easy way out to run them anyway, you're an a$$hole who doesn't deserve the horse you are ruining.
I'm not talking about those who inject for the heck of it before having any diagnostics done, I mean when the horse legit needs those injections, and the owner refuses because they are too cheap or too stupid to get them done while running a lame horse into the ground, then they are not going to stay on my good side very long, and I cannot promise my actions won't reflect that.
I'm also using 'you' as a hypothetical. This is not directed at anyone in particular right now, but I guess if the shoe fits..... | |
| | |
Expert
Posts: 4766
       Location: Bandera, TX | I will inject. However, you have Autologous Conditioned Serum, Shockwave and PEMF that could be tried. | |
| | |
 Extreme Veteran
Posts: 336
   
|
Was injecting my horses hocks every 2 months,,,started him on previcox and pentosan and he doesn't need inject, anymore,,,and he has arthritis
Good Luck!1 | |
| | |
 Elite Veteran
Posts: 1161
   
| My horse has navicular and many other joint problem shocks included did one set of hock injections last 6 months. New vet recommended adequin started doing that every 6 weeks no problems. He got his shot lay one time and he was sore I do know he needs his adequin... | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 3782
        Location: Gainesville, TX | Personally I'm not against injecting but there are certainly a few things you can do to prolong time between injections and things people will do to avoid them. A first line of defense would be rest and regular icing. Some people like oral joint supplements (personally I don't feed these though I've tried a couple). Better are injectable joint supplements like Adequan, Pentosan, and Legend. Now people also have Osphos they can try too and Tildren for navicular. NSAIDS are always great for short term, Previcox & Bute. Some people like banamine too. There are also alternative therapies like magnets, acupuncture, massage, chiropractic, lasers, PEMF, and even heat with BOT wraps. There are sometimes shoeing options to help change angles and relieve pressure. Then there are more conservative joint injection options like IRAP and stem cells which rebuild instead of tearing down cartilage. And then of course there are different qualities and types of injections depending on the joint.
All this being considered, I understand that with the number of treatment options that people would want to try the more conservative ones for a while. Sometimes this is a good strategy and sometimes they are best paired with traditional injections, but I do understand. Hubby and I have talked about this quite a bit as we've only recently faced this dilemma with my young mare. We're combining therapies and I can tell you she's been xrayed and lameness checked out the wazoo. She's never actually limped but she's been sore. We tried a number of more conservative options before going with injections. Currently we are combining adequan, magnets, icing, rest, liniment massage, shoeing changes, irap and traditional injections to keep her happy and comfortable. Vet said she was moving very well at our last visit and my farrier has been particularly happy with her new hoof growth as she really likes to grow toe and not much heel. Overall I think we are making great progress but certainly we are using injections. | |
| | |
 I Chore in Chucks
Posts: 2882
        Location: MD | Exactly what Biblia said. it wouldn't let me quote it!
| |
| | |
 Half-Eaten Cookies
Posts: 2076
    Location: Fort Worth / Springtown | I'm a firm believer in raw apple cider vinegar for many things - including arthritis. It's getting harder to find in gallon jugs, so I've started making it.
I've given injections at vet's advice -- but if you are looking for alternatives, I'd definitely try ^^^^ | |
| | |
 You get what you give
Posts: 13030
     Location: Texas | cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM
outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM
So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections?
Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion?
Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high.
Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states.
Not to mention the renal disease that any NSAID given over time can cause.. no one wants kidney failure. | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 1612
   Location: Cocoa, Florida | I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses.
The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain. | |
| | |
Elite Veteran
Posts: 865
     
| RnRJack - 2015-10-20 12:04 PM
I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses.
The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain.
I totally agree with you on the cortisone injections. I have a small tear in my rotator cuff. Very painful and they tried to talk me into surgery. Forget that! I opted for injections. I go every 6-8 months and 90% of the pain is gone. So why not do the same for our horses. It's not like you can get them hock surgery to aleve the pain. Of course the joints will only take so many injections so you have to use judgement and not inject too often. JMO | |
| | |
 Go For It!
     Location: Texas | RnRJack - 2015-10-20 12:04 PM
I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses.
The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain.
I understand that we have to work to make a living... But if you had an opportunity to rest and rehab that injury, it can heal. Unfortunately, that may not be an option for you.
Back to the original question...
Our horses can benefit a great deal from some down time and rehab. I've often wondered why people take a horse that is sore, go to the vet and spend $500.00+ on x-rays and injections so that they can go to the $35.00 jackpot and win $150.00. That just doesn't make much sense to me.
I'm all about preventative medicine. I will spend extra on things to keep my horses fit and feeling good before I would consider injections. I haven't needed to inject a horse in 15 years and I've not had any issues, knock on wood. I'm certainly not against injections to manage an issue that can't be treated with time off and some rehab, but I believe that injections are far too common these days. They are treated as a cure-all by lots of folks. Vets do them because WE want SOMETHING done. A quick fix so to speak. Problem is... they aren't curing the problem, simply masking it.
| |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 1612
   Location: Cocoa, Florida | Rest is not an option, no, you're correct but I've been doing everything my doctor has had me do, physical therapy, anti inflammatory medicine, icing etc. it has gotten a little better but it's been months and months and it's really taking a toll on me, I know a tendon in my elbow and hock injections aren't totally relevant but if it's a last option, I would do it to make them comfortable!
I believe in preventative maintainence as well! I'm a big believer in adequen and a few other joint supplements.
Edited by RnRJack 2015-10-20 10:32 PM
| |
| | |
The Advice Guru
Posts: 6419
     
| classicpotatochip - 2015-10-19 9:00 PM
cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM
outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM
So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections?
Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion?
Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high.
Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states.
Dr Honnas doesn't do them. He refers them to Dr Hague in Edmond, Ok. I am currently 14 months out and waiting for soundness to return to one that I had fused. I don't regret doing it, I didn't have a horse either way, and he should eventually come sound again. Hypothetically and optimistically, best case scenario. But it isn't always a peaches and cream surgery. Everyone needs to go into that with their eyes open, for sure.
Thanks I knew the name started with an H.
I'm sorry you haven't got the soundness. Did they test for communication between the lower and upper joint, I can't remember the name. My vet was the lead author on the research, and he does this study before surgery, if they have communication, he will not do them.
Also did you inject with cortisone, bethamethasolone, or depo before fusing? If you did there is a very small chance you will get the positive outcome. My vet won't fuse any horses who have been injected with the above, as the later research showed the bones don't fuse.
This is why I don't inject, I will fuse. I have done 3 horses all with success.
As others have said, i do major prevention now so I don't have to fuse or inject. | |
| | |
  Whack and Roll
Posts: 6342
      Location: NE Texas | grinandbareit - 2015-10-20 8:19 PM
RnRJack - 2015-10-20 12:04 PM
I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses.
The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain.
I understand that we have to work to make a living... But if you had an opportunity to rest and rehab that injury, it can heal. Unfortunately, that may not be an option for you.
Back to the original question...
Our horses can benefit a great deal from some down time and rehab. I've often wondered why people take a horse that is sore, go to the vet and spend $500.00+ on x-rays and injections so that they can go to the $35.00 jackpot and win $150.00. That just doesn't make much sense to me.
I'm all about preventative medicine. I will spend extra on things to keep my horses fit and feeling good before I would consider injections. I haven't needed to inject a horse in 15 years and I've not had any issues, knock on wood. I'm certainly not against injections to manage an issue that can't be treated with time off and some rehab, but I believe that injections are far too common these days. They are treated as a cure-all by lots of folks. Vets do them because WE want SOMETHING done. A quick fix so to speak. Problem is... they aren't curing the problem, simply masking it.
Best post I've read on here in a very long time. We'll said grinandbareit!!! | |
| | |
 Elite Veteran
Posts: 669
    Location: Central Texas | Bibliafarm - 2015-10-19 8:17 PM
Nevertooold - 2015-10-19 8:10 PM I'm not against injections when they are needed. I'm against people giving their horses injections with out making sure what the problem is.
I had a horse blowing off of barrels and what he needed was an adjustment and massage body work.
Drives me nuts when people are injecting joints and calling it maintenance on young horses. JMO
I do know from personal experience, how well the joint injections can relive pain.
  ditto
ditto! I know people who are injecting very very young horses already and they are basically only weekend warriors. Not my circus and not my monkeys but I sure hate to see them start that young injecting. That being said, I have injected but sparingly and only on older horses. I use Pentosan now days. | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 1612
   Location: Cocoa, Florida | I think most of the problem is that people always blame hocks first when it can be a number of things making the horse sore but they don't want to take the time or $ to find the source before injecting. I always x-Ray hocks before I inject or treat them to make sure that is indeed the cause and see if there is any other options first. Injections are my last option.
Yes I would give myself a shot of cortisone for my tennis elbow, and I've had one in my wrist that I broke twice as well, but that was also a last desperate option. | |
| | |
 Extreme Veteran
Posts: 434
     Location: Northwest Florida | grinandbareit - 2015-10-20 8:19 PM
RnRJack - 2015-10-20 12:04 PM
I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses.
The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain.
I understand that we have to work to make a living... But if you had an opportunity to rest and rehab that injury, it can heal. Unfortunately, that may not be an option for you.
Back to the original question...
Our horses can benefit a great deal from some down time and rehab. I've often wondered why people take a horse that is sore, go to the vet and spend $500.00+ on x-rays and injections so that they can go to the $35.00 jackpot and win $150.00. That just doesn't make much sense to me.
I'm all about preventative medicine. I will spend extra on things to keep my horses fit and feeling good before I would consider injections. I haven't needed to inject a horse in 15 years and I've not had any issues, knock on wood. I'm certainly not against injections to manage an issue that can't be treated with time off and some rehab, but I believe that injections are far too common these days. They are treated as a cure-all by lots of folks. Vets do them because WE want SOMETHING done. A quick fix so to speak. Problem is... they aren't curing the problem, simply masking it.
 | |
| | |
  Warmblood with Wings
Posts: 27846
           Location: Florida.. | I think People over inject anything they think is sore or needs it to mask issues.. as far as hocks fusing... I injected my boy about every 6 months hed be painfully sore in hocks after I did xrays and confirmed..my quarter horse..
with our jumpers and dressage horses its not as common.. I had only injected one gelding.. in all my years..kinda odd but we dont do it like barrel racers.. we do alot of other things but dont inject very often.. we train hard.. we use hind end.. we work them we give them time off if needed and do maintenance.. I am not sure why its so common in the barrel racing industry..and areas we would dont consider injecting but we do accupuncture alot and laser therapy and other alternatives....time off if sore etc.....I realize differant work, differant muscles and the fast turns etc are hard but our jumpers do it but longer periods ..Im not saying negative just have always thought about that.. we do warm up differantly and for long periods,, conditioning is a huge key factor.. but I know alot of the BRs condition to ..just something I have always thought about.. | |
| | |
 Elite Veteran
Posts: 878
       Location: "...way down south in the Everglades..." | grinandbareit - 2015-10-20 9:19 PM RnRJack - 2015-10-20 12:04 PM I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses. The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain. I understand that we have to work to make a living... But if you had an opportunity to rest and rehab that injury, it can heal. Unfortunately, that may not be an option for you. Back to the original question... Our horses can benefit a great deal from some down time and rehab. I've often wondered why people take a horse that is sore, go to the vet and spend $500.00+ on x-rays and injections so that they can go to the $35.00 jackpot and win $150.00. That just doesn't make much sense to me. I'm all about preventative medicine. I will spend extra on things to keep my horses fit and feeling good before I would consider injections. I haven't needed to inject a horse in 15 years and I've not had any issues, knock on wood. I'm certainly not against injections to manage an issue that can't be treated with time off and some rehab, but I believe that injections are far too common these days. They are treated as a cure-all by lots of folks. Vets do them because WE want SOMETHING done. A quick fix so to speak. Problem is... they aren't curing the problem, simply masking it.
Totally agree with Grin and bare it... My take is if rest and other alternatives do not yeild results then injections may be warranted. But I will say that injections aren't always magical heal all solutions. I had a hunter pony and we injected his hocks several times, honestly didn't make much of a difference. I also know with myself that with my torn rotator cuff I didn't find any relief with the cortisone shots. I think the first shot helped for about a week, the second didn't seem to help at all. So I think it is relative to the person/horse as whether or not they respond. With my shoulder I found a combo of time, PT, and basic pain management was the most helpful. With the pony, we ended up giving him some much needed breaks and various supplements and therapies to assist. He ended up having a long career but we had to manage it carefully as to not over-do-it with his schedule. | |
| | |
Rad Dork
Posts: 5218
   Location: Oklahoma | G&BI, do you do any type of preventative injections? Such as Adequan, Legend, NexHA, etc that aren't IA?
Just curious! | |
| | |
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 502
 Location: United States | I believe it is critical to talk/build a relationship with a vet that practices continuing education. Also, take it upon your self to read studies, talk to your vet about studies and be open minded. I worked closely with a boarded sport medicine doctor (best time of my life BTW) and I am cautious of what I say because its not my position to speak I am not a doctor. I will share that I observed peoples interpretation of a horse that needs "maintenance help" is a lot of times different. What sally thinks helps her horse, may not help Susans horse or (example) Sally may get on Susan's horse and not think it needs joint maintenance, just training. Its often interpretation and a riders tolerance and experience level, horses fitness level, the footing... the list goes on and on. There are also MANY variables involved, and that is why it is important to read studies that were done on a large number of horses, not just ten. I inject my hard running and turning barrel horse JMO. Best money spent and it keeps my horse feeling super. | |
| | |
 Go For It!
     Location: Texas | Longneck - 2015-10-21 9:00 AM
G&BI, do you do any type of preventative injections? Such as Adequan, Legend, NexHA, etc that aren't IA?
Just curious!
I do give Adequan on a regular basis. Once a year, in the spring I will do a full series on both horses. I will give it weekly if I'm hauling pretty hard as well. If I am only going to the big stuff then I will give a shot 10 days out and again 3 days out. I also feed flax seed and oats with alfalfa hay and a probiotic. They really don't get anything in their diet that causes any inflammation because I don't feed any processed feed.
Another thing that I think makes a HUGE difference is having them really fit. Making sure their topline and hips, hamstrings, etc. are strong. Much like us, when we build up that core it helps to take the strain off the joints. When we use the muscles correctly and keep them healthy it makes it easier on their body as a whole, and they work more efficiently, which shows up on the clock.
I haven't always done things this way. Much of this I have learned the hard way. It's just like anything else, the more you learn the better you do, and the better you do, the more you want to learn.
I will say this too... If my horses happen to get a little sore, I give them time off. I have found, in my experience, that a bit of time off is often the best medicine you can prescribe.
| |
| | |
  Warmblood with Wings
Posts: 27846
           Location: Florida.. | grinandbareit - 2015-10-21 12:01 PM Longneck - 2015-10-21 9:00 AM G&BI, do you do any type of preventative injections? Such as Adequan, Legend, NexHA, etc that aren't IA? Just curious! I do give Adequan on a regular basis. Once a year, in the spring I will do a full series on both horses. I will give it weekly if I'm hauling pretty hard as well. If I am only going to the big stuff then I will give a shot 10 days out and again 3 days out. I also feed flax seed and oats with alfalfa hay and a probiotic. They really don't get anything in their diet that causes any inflammation because I don't feed any processed feed. Another thing that I think makes a HUGE difference is having them really fit. Making sure their topline and hips, hamstrings, etc. are strong. Much like us, when we build up that core it helps to take the strain off the joints. When we use the muscles correctly and keep them healthy it makes it easier on their body as a whole, and they work more efficiently, which shows up on the clock. I haven't always done things this way. Much of this I have learned the hard way. It's just like anything else, the more you learn the better you do, and the better you do, the more you want to learn. I will say this too... If my horses happen to get a little sore, I give them time off. I have found, in my experience, that a bit of time off is often the best medicine you can prescribe.
Bingo.... | |
| | |
Industrial Srength Barrel Racer
Posts: 7268
     
| Speedy Buckeye Girl - 2015-10-21 8:31 AM
grinandbareit - 2015-10-20 9:19 PM RnRJack - 2015-10-20 12:04 PM I have tennis elbow, excruciating tendon pain in my arm and elbow. I do hair all day and come home and clean stalls, cleaning stalls is excruciating BUT I have to do it, just like sore hocks are excruciating, the horse with a big heart HAs to do it. I bear through the pain to get my job done, and so do our horses. The moral of this story is, I'm going to get a shot of cortisone later this week so I can do my job and not feel any pain. I understand that we have to work to make a living... But if you had an opportunity to rest and rehab that injury, it can heal. Unfortunately, that may not be an option for you. Back to the original question... Our horses can benefit a great deal from some down time and rehab. I've often wondered why people take a horse that is sore, go to the vet and spend $500.00+ on x-rays and injections so that they can go to the $35.00 jackpot and win $150.00. That just doesn't make much sense to me. I'm all about preventative medicine. I will spend extra on things to keep my horses fit and feeling good before I would consider injections. I haven't needed to inject a horse in 15 years and I've not had any issues, knock on wood. I'm certainly not against injections to manage an issue that can't be treated with time off and some rehab, but I believe that injections are far too common these days. They are treated as a cure-all by lots of folks. Vets do them because WE want SOMETHING done. A quick fix so to speak. Problem is... they aren't curing the problem, simply masking it.
Totally agree with Grin and bare it... My take is if rest and other alternatives do not yeild results then injections may be warranted. But I will say that injections aren't always magical heal all solutions. I had a hunter pony and we injected his hocks several times, honestly didn't make much of a difference. I also know with myself that with my torn rotator cuff I didn't find any relief with the cortisone shots. I think the first shot helped for about a week, the second didn't seem to help at all. So I think it is relative to the person/horse as whether or not they respond. With my shoulder I found a combo of time, PT, and basic pain management was the most helpful. With the pony, we ended up giving him some much needed breaks and various supplements and therapies to assist. He ended up having a long career but we had to manage it carefully as to not over-do-it with his schedule.
I agree with both of you. I'm NOT a fan of injecting for various reasons. If that was my last resort, I would consider it but in 30 years of running barrel horses I've never injected yet - then AGAIN, I am NOT a die-hard, HAVE to enter every single race within a 500 mile radius either. | |
| | |
Rad Dork
Posts: 5218
   Location: Oklahoma | grinandbareit - 2015-10-21 11:01 AM
Longneck - 2015-10-21 9:00 AM
G&BI, do you do any type of preventative injections? Such as Adequan, Legend, NexHA, etc that aren't IA?
Just curious!
I do give Adequan on a regular basis. Once a year, in the spring I will do a full series on both horses. I will give it weekly if I'm hauling pretty hard as well. If I am only going to the big stuff then I will give a shot 10 days out and again 3 days out. I also feed flax seed and oats with alfalfa hay and a probiotic. They really don't get anything in their diet that causes any inflammation because I don't feed any processed feed.
Another thing that I think makes a HUGE difference is having them really fit. Making sure their topline and hips, hamstrings, etc. are strong. Much like us, when we build up that core it helps to take the strain off the joints. When we use the muscles correctly and keep them healthy it makes it easier on their body as a whole, and they work more efficiently, which shows up on the clock.
I haven't always done things this way. Much of this I have learned the hard way. It's just like anything else, the more you learn the better you do, and the better you do, the more you want to learn.
I will say this too... If my horses happen to get a little sore, I give them time off. I have found, in my experience, that a bit of time off is often the best medicine you can prescribe.
Thank you, thank you! | |
| | |
Red Bull Agressive
Posts: 5981
         Location: North Dakota | Bibliafarm - 2015-10-21 8:17 AM I think People over inject anything they think is sore or needs it to mask issues.. as far as hocks fusing... I injected my boy about every 6 months hed be painfully sore in hocks after I did xrays and confirmed..my quarter horse..
with our jumpers and dressage horses its not as common.. I had only injected one gelding.. in all my years..kinda odd but we dont do it like barrel racers.. we do alot of other things but dont inject very often.. we train hard.. we use hind end.. we work them we give them time off if needed and do maintenance.. I am not sure why its so common in the barrel racing industry..and areas we would dont consider injecting but we do accupuncture alot and laser therapy and other alternatives....time off if sore etc.....I realize differant work, differant muscles and the fast turns etc are hard but our jumpers do it but longer periods ..Im not saying negative just have always thought about that.. we do warm up differantly and for long periods,, conditioning is a huge key factor.. but I know alot of the BRs condition to ..just something I have always thought about.. I have noticed this too over the years. I rode with grand prix jumpers and dressage riders, top level hunters, all that and never heard of injections or half the therapies out there that are so common for barrel horses. Now I think it's great to do all you can for your horse, but my personal theory as to why it's not as common in the english world is starting the horses under saddle later and more focus on true engagement and straightness. Horses allowed to mature and using themselves properly aren't going to wear out their joints as fast. And I hate to say it but a lot of barrel racers I know don't focus on those things enough...
Edited by cavyrunsbarrels 2015-10-21 1:50 PM
| |
| | |
 Don't Wanna Make This Awkward
Posts: 3106
   Location: Texas | cheryl makofka - 2015-10-20 11:05 PM classicpotatochip - 2015-10-19 9:00 PM cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections? Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion? Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high. Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states. Dr Honnas doesn't do them. He refers them to Dr Hague in Edmond, Ok. I am currently 14 months out and waiting for soundness to return to one that I had fused. I don't regret doing it, I didn't have a horse either way, and he should eventually come sound again. Hypothetically and optimistically, best case scenario. But it isn't always a peaches and cream surgery. Everyone needs to go into that with their eyes open, for sure. Thanks I knew the name started with an H. I'm sorry you haven't got the soundness. Did they test for communication between the lower and upper joint, I can't remember the name. My vet was the lead author on the research, and he does this study before surgery, if they have communication, he will not do them. Also did you inject with cortisone, bethamethasolone, or depo before fusing? If you did there is a very small chance you will get the positive outcome. My vet won't fuse any horses who have been injected with the above, as the later research showed the bones don't fuse. This is why I don't inject, I will fuse. I have done 3 horses all with success. As others have said, i do major prevention now so I don't have to fuse or inject.
Cheryl what age do you have your horses hocks fused? I would assume they have to be fully grown before fusing, but maybe not.
| |
| | |
 Don't Wanna Make This Awkward
Posts: 3106
   Location: Texas | cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-21 1:49 PM Bibliafarm - 2015-10-21 8:17 AM I think People over inject anything they think is sore or needs it to mask issues.. as far as hocks fusing... I injected my boy about every 6 months hed be painfully sore in hocks after I did xrays and confirmed..my quarter horse..
with our jumpers and dressage horses its not as common.. I had only injected one gelding.. in all my years..kinda odd but we dont do it like barrel racers.. we do alot of other things but dont inject very often.. we train hard.. we use hind end.. we work them we give them time off if needed and do maintenance.. I am not sure why its so common in the barrel racing industry..and areas we would dont consider injecting but we do accupuncture alot and laser therapy and other alternatives....time off if sore etc.....I realize differant work, differant muscles and the fast turns etc are hard but our jumpers do it but longer periods ..Im not saying negative just have always thought about that.. we do warm up differantly and for long periods,, conditioning is a huge key factor.. but I know alot of the BRs condition to ..just something I have always thought about.. I have noticed this too over the years. I rode with grand prix jumpers and dressage riders, top level hunters, all that and never heard of injections or half the therapies out there that are so common for barrel horses. Now I think it's great to do all you can for your horse, but my personal theory as to why it's not as common in the english world is starting the horses under saddle later and more focus on true engagement and straightness. Horses allowed to mature and using themselves properly aren't going to wear out their joints as fast. And I hate to say it but a lot of barrel racers I know don't focus on those things enough...
I do fully agree with this.. Prime age for barrel horse is usually around 12 which seems that way for every discipline, but with futurities raising the added money so much and becoming so popular people seem to be trying to get the most out of their horses by their 4 year old year. It's really a shame I think. When I rode english most of our horses were much older 12-18 usually, and I remember we had a mare that was 8 and that seemed so young. Now barrel racing it seems old. | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 1612
   Location: Cocoa, Florida | I give adequen also to my horses that I'm hauling and running a lot, also omeprozol and aloe Vera juice as a preventative (stomach smoother) does anyone feed MSM anymore? I give my two running mares MSM still, it's kind of an old school supplement huh? I used a holistic vet that doesn't believe in it, can anyone tell me why? | |
| | |
  Warmblood with Wings
Posts: 27846
           Location: Florida.. | RnRJack - 2015-10-21 10:47 PM I give adequen also to my horses that I'm hauling and running a lot, also omeprozol and aloe Vera juice as a preventative (stomach smoother) does anyone feed MSM anymore? I give my two running mares MSM still, it's kind of an old school supplement huh? I used a holistic vet that doesn't believe in it, can anyone tell me why?
I have used it I dont know how it is long term on tummys but never had a issue with t. | |
| | |
I AM being nice
Posts: 4396
        Location: MD | I have to say, I feel as though many of the people who are saying that we don't see as many injections in the English disciplines were obviously not either in upper level programs, or "in the know" as to what was going on.
There really isn't so much of a difference in the level and/or types of maintenance that the English horses get versus the barrel horses. If you have actual experience in both arenas, you'll get what I'm saying. You can go to any local, schooling type hunter show and watch a bunch of lesson horses packing a kid around the Short Stirrup Hunter class who's stifles are obviously shot. Maybe they have a bit of an uneven stride in the trot while hacking. Those same type horses are being loped through with little Susie at your local barrel race, being whipped on in an attempt to win the 4D in the Youth. The difference is that in the Hunter world, little Susie's trainers say nothing about the unsoundness, nor bring up joint injections. In the barrel racing world, little Susie's mom, who has never ridden a horse is her trainer and she is sitting on the fence screaming at Susie to whip harder. Susie's mom then gets on an online forum, maybe posts a video and 1,000 "internet vets" say they think that Susie's horse Spot looks very sore and that she should have his hocks checked.
While Dressage horses are often dealt with quite differently, I can guarantee you that the top show Hunters, Jumpers and 3 Day Event horses become very good friends with their vets. Not only that, how many of you have ever been to say the Winter Equestrian Festival, in Wellington, FL. Take a walk through someone's barn (only if invited, of course) and take a peek in the feed room while you're at it. That big wipe board, that's the med list. I promise you that pretty much every horse in the barn is going to be on it. Those horses get more needles than most of the horses at the NFR. It only stands to reason. We'll say that while at a multi week show, a good Hunter is showing 3 or 4 days a week. That sucker is going to be on a longe line, cantering around for at least an hour and more likely two or three before each day of showing. That sort of wear and tear on one's body dictates that they are going to be sore.
I can also tell you from personal experience that the 3 Day Event crowd are worse than barrel racers when it comes to injections. Those horses are truly the iron horses of Equestrian sport. Not only do they almost have to be a Dressage horse, they have to be adept at jumping a 1.20 meter show jump course and they have to be fit enough to gallop a cross country course, up and down terrain. Until recently, the Dressage phase of an Event was something that one "Must do in order to get to the fun part". Due to this, many riders never truly learned how to do it well. The horses were flatted in a very false manner, their heads pulled to their chests, completely lacking in engagement and very hollow through their spine. This led to the fact that many were having their SI injected. There was a time when in that world, you heard people telling others to get their horses SI done as frequently as we hear barrel racers discussing hocks.
I do believe that too many people are not educated enough about joint injections. I also feel as though even fewer are properly educated about good quality leg care and conditioning. Why do leg work during the week to keep one sound when they can just go get their horse injected every six months? Most of those folks have no idea what their horse is being injected with, don't know what the joint looked like, nor know if the joint was dry, full of fluid, if the fluid was gritty/bloody. All they know is that their horse got his hocks done so he should win the barrel race this weekend. This again, I attribute to a lack of education. It scares me that even quite a few professionals, who are out winning big stuff, have no clue what to do for a horse beyond take it to the vet and say "It's not turning. Fix it!".
All of this being said, I will be the first to inject one if they need it. I don't play games with my horse's joint health. If one tells me that they're having an issue, it gets addressed. If injecting it along with the other care that it receives is the best route to take at the time, that's what I'll do. If one really needs time off, I'll give them as much time as they need. I think that people overreact to young horses being injected . A lot of people tend to believe that once you inject, you will always have to inject. I feel that this was almost proven to be true for a long time. In my mind, the reason for that is because a horse with an issue would be left and run on that bad joint until it got to the point that it crippled up. The owner finally took it to the vet, the horse was injected, came sound and started performing again. Six months later, the horse started exhibiting signs of pain again. Back to the vet, new set of injections and viola! The thing that people must realize is that due to their negligence in not having addressed the issue sooner, irreparable damage was done. As a result, yes your horse does now require bi-annual injections. This is the fault of the negligent owner, not the injection.
| |
| | |
The Advice Guru
Posts: 6419
     
| outrundaizy - 2015-10-21 1:59 PM
cheryl makofka - 2015-10-20 11:05 PM classicpotatochip - 2015-10-19 9:00 PM cheryl makofka - 2015-10-19 6:33 PM outrundaizy - 2015-10-19 1:15 PM So I know there are some people out there who simply won't inject their horses.. I'm curious, say you have a horse that is blowing off barrels, you take it to the vet, vet says horse needs hocks injected, xrays show signs of arthritis. You take the horse to 2 other vets both with the same outcome. How do you treat this? What are things you do without injections? Why would you want to go against 3 vets opinion? Problem with everything, is you only mask the issue, previcoxx, I was reading in a pharmacology text, (got a new one cause I am a nerd ) it says at higher doses previcoxx will inhibit both cox 1 and 2 therefore causing ulcers. The text said any NSAID at high doses will inhibit both cox 1-2 and cause ulcers. We are talking the high dose of normal, not insanely high. Hocks, I actually don't inject, I fuse by surgical laser, then I never have to think of them again, I believe dr Honas does them for 2500, and he is the coauthor/researcher for the surgical laser fusion, so he would be the best in the states. Dr Honnas doesn't do them. He refers them to Dr Hague in Edmond, Ok. I am currently 14 months out and waiting for soundness to return to one that I had fused. I don't regret doing it, I didn't have a horse either way, and he should eventually come sound again. Hypothetically and optimistically, best case scenario. But it isn't always a peaches and cream surgery. Everyone needs to go into that with their eyes open, for sure. Thanks I knew the name started with an H. I'm sorry you haven't got the soundness. Did they test for communication between the lower and upper joint, I can't remember the name. My vet was the lead author on the research, and he does this study before surgery, if they have communication, he will not do them. Also did you inject with cortisone, bethamethasolone, or depo before fusing? If you did there is a very small chance you will get the positive outcome. My vet won't fuse any horses who have been injected with the above, as the later research showed the bones don't fuse. This is why I don't inject, I will fuse. I have done 3 horses all with success. As others have said, i do major prevention now so I don't have to fuse or inject.
Cheryl what age do you have your horses hocks fused? I would assume they have to be fully grown before fusing, but maybe not.
One was done a 8
The other 2 were done at 6
The 8 yr olds hocks were brutal, he had bone spurs hooking the tendon, still don't know how he was running before. He needed to be fused and the spurs burned off. He was a 1d horse on certain pens before, after his times increased by half a second.
One 6 yr old quit turning his first, flexion tests showed hocks, xrays showed he shattered one of the joints, to sped up the healing process he was done, and no he never had any heat swelling in the hock
The last 6 yr old wasn't broke till 3 rode hardly at all till 6 sent him to a trainer who noticed something wasn't right, took him to the vet xrays show pretty bad arthritis that could be maintained with injections but I opted for fusion. Vets theory on this one was he was malnourished under the age of two to cause the early deterioration.
I don't fuse unless I have to, and currently my horses have showed no symptoms of hock pain. I have them on lubrysin during their riding months, and they get a 3 month vacation each year. They also don't do barrel work till they are fit.
Edited by cheryl makofka 2015-10-21 11:31 PM
| |
| | |
 Don't Wanna Make This Awkward
Posts: 3106
   Location: Texas | WrapSnap - 2015-10-21 11:11 PM I have to say, I feel as though many of the people who are saying that we don't see as many injections in the English disciplines were obviously not either in upper level programs, or "in the know" as to what was going on. There really isn't so much of a difference in the level and/or types of maintenance that the English horses get versus the barrel horses. If you have actual experience in both arenas, you'll get what I'm saying. You can go to any local, schooling type hunter show and watch a bunch of lesson horses packing a kid around the Short Stirrup Hunter class who's stifles are obviously shot. Maybe they have a bit of an uneven stride in the trot while hacking. Those same type horses are being loped through with little Susie at your local barrel race, being whipped on in an attempt to win the 4D in the Youth. The difference is that in the Hunter world, little Susie's trainers say nothing about the unsoundness, nor bring up joint injections. In the barrel racing world, little Susie's mom, who has never ridden a horse is her trainer and she is sitting on the fence screaming at Susie to whip harder. Susie's mom then gets on an online forum, maybe posts a video and 1,000 "internet vets" say they think that Susie's horse Spot looks very sore and that she should have his hocks checked. While Dressage horses are often dealt with quite differently, I can guarantee you that the top show Hunters, Jumpers and 3 Day Event horses become very good friends with their vets. Not only that, how many of you have ever been to say the Winter Equestrian Festival, in Wellington, FL. Take a walk through someone's barn (only if invited, of course) and take a peek in the feed room while you're at it. That big wipe board, that's the med list. I promise you that pretty much every horse in the barn is going to be on it. Those horses get more needles than most of the horses at the NFR. It only stands to reason. We'll say that while at a multi week show, a good Hunter is showing 3 or 4 days a week. That sucker is going to be on a longe line, cantering around for at least an hour and more likely two or three before each day of showing. That sort of wear and tear on one's body dictates that they are going to be sore. I can also tell you from personal experience that the 3 Day Event crowd are worse than barrel racers when it comes to injections. Those horses are truly the iron horses of Equestrian sport. Not only do they almost have to be a Dressage horse, they have to be adept at jumping a 1.20 meter show jump course and they have to be fit enough to gallop a cross country course, up and down terrain. Until recently, the Dressage phase of an Event was something that one "Must do in order to get to the fun part". Due to this, many riders never truly learned how to do it well. The horses were flatted in a very false manner, their heads pulled to their chests, completely lacking in engagement and very hollow through their spine. This led to the fact that many were having their SI injected. There was a time when in that world, you heard people telling others to get their horses SI done as frequently as we hear barrel racers discussing hocks. I do believe that too many people are not educated enough about joint injections. I also feel as though even fewer are properly educated about good quality leg care and conditioning. Why do leg work during the week to keep one sound when they can just go get their horse injected every six months? Most of those folks have no idea what their horse is being injected with, don't know what the joint looked like, nor know if the joint was dry, full of fluid, if the fluid was gritty/bloody. All they know is that their horse got his hocks done so he should win the barrel race this weekend. This again, I attribute to a lack of education. It scares me that even quite a few professionals, who are out winning big stuff, have no clue what to do for a horse beyond take it to the vet and say "It's not turning. Fix it!". All of this being said, I will be the first to inject one if they need it. I don't play games with my horse's joint health. If one tells me that they're having an issue, it gets addressed. If injecting it along with the other care that it receives is the best route to take at the time, that's what I'll do. If one really needs time off, I'll give them as much time as they need. I think that people overreact to young horses being injected . A lot of people tend to believe that once you inject, you will always have to inject. I feel that this was almost proven to be true for a long time. In my mind, the reason for that is because a horse with an issue would be left and run on that bad joint until it got to the point that it crippled up. The owner finally took it to the vet, the horse was injected, came sound and started performing again. Six months later, the horse started exhibiting signs of pain again. Back to the vet, new set of injections and viola! The thing that people must realize is that due to their negligence in not having addressed the issue sooner, irreparable damage was done. As a result, yes your horse does now require bi-annual injections. This is the fault of the negligent owner, not the injection.
This was extremely helpful. Thank you.
And I'll be the first to say the only time I ever showed in the english world were at shows smaller than a playday. I can only imagine what went on at that barn that I was oblivious too lol | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 1612
   Location: Cocoa, Florida | I grew up in the English world, I had a trainer that would literally drug every horse that was somewhat hot when he had someone coming out to try them out for sale. I never said anything nor did I mention it to him as I hacked all his horses out and got free lessons for it. I knew it was wrong but I still kept my mouth shut. I have also seen barrel racers do it to "take the edge off". Problem is, when my old English trainer gave to much Ace to my best friends thoroughbred he just happened to pull his shoulder really bad that same day and had to take an 8 month break! Now whether the Ace aided in the injury or not I can say, either way it wasn't right what he was doing. I've seen more dishonest things go on in my hunter jumper barn then in the barrel racing world, the only difference is that the English people didn't brag about it.
Either way, I would agree with Andy that both disciplines inject just as often. | |
| | |
 Don't Ask Me
Posts: 4077
    
| RnRJack - 2015-10-22 1:24 AM I grew up in the English world, I had a trainer that would literally drug every horse that was somewhat hot when he had someone coming out to try them out for sale. I never said anything nor did I mention it to him as I hacked all his horses out and got free lessons for it. I knew it was wrong but I still kept my mouth shut. I have also seen barrel racers do it to "take the edge off". Problem is, when my old English trainer gave to much Ace to my best friends thoroughbred he just happened to pull his shoulder really bad that same day and had to take an 8 month break! Now whether the Ace aided in the injury or not I can say, either way it wasn't right what he was doing. I've seen more dishonest things go on in my hunter jumper barn then in the barrel racing world, the only difference is that the English people didn't brag about it. Either way, I would agree with Andy that both disciplines inject just as often.
i agree with this statement-- barrelracers seemed to honestly say how long till i run cause i need to drug my horse. where i have never heard that in the english world myself | |
| | |
 Balance Beam and more...
Posts: 11511
    Location: 31 lengths farms | WrapSnap - 2015-10-22 9:11 PM
I have to say, I feel as though many of the people who are saying that we don't see as many injections in the English disciplines were obviously not either in upper level programs, or "in the know" as to what was going on.
There really isn't so much of a difference in the level and/or types of maintenance that the English horses get versus the barrel horses. If you have actual experience in both arenas, you'll get what I'm saying. You can go to any local, schooling type hunter show and watch a bunch of lesson horses packing a kid around the Short Stirrup Hunter class who's stifles are obviously shot. Maybe they have a bit of an uneven stride in the trot while hacking. Those same type horses are being loped through with little Susie at your local barrel race, being whipped on in an attempt to win the 4D in the Youth. The difference is that in the Hunter world, little Susie's trainers say nothing about the unsoundness, nor bring up joint injections. In the barrel racing world, little Susie's mom, who has never ridden a horse is her trainer and she is sitting on the fence screaming at Susie to whip harder. Susie's mom then gets on an online forum, maybe posts a video and 1,000 "internet vets" say they think that Susie's horse Spot looks very sore and that she should have his hocks checked.
While Dressage horses are often dealt with quite differently, I can guarantee you that the top show Hunters, Jumpers and 3 Day Event horses become very good friends with their vets. Not only that, how many of you have ever been to say the Winter Equestrian Festival, in Wellington, FL. Take a walk through someone's barn (only if invited, of course) and take a peek in the feed room while you're at it. That big wipe board, that's the med list. I promise you that pretty much every horse in the barn is going to be on it. Those horses get more needles than most of the horses at the NFR. It only stands to reason. We'll say that while at a multi week show, a good Hunter is showing 3 or 4 days a week. That sucker is going to be on a longe line, cantering around for at least an hour and more likely two or three before each day of showing. That sort of wear and tear on one's body dictates that they are going to be sore.
I can also tell you from personal experience that the 3 Day Event crowd are worse than barrel racers when it comes to injections. Those horses are truly the iron horses of Equestrian sport. Not only do they almost have to be a Dressage horse, they have to be adept at jumping a 1.20 meter show jump course and they have to be fit enough to gallop a cross country course, up and down terrain. Until recently, the Dressage phase of an Event was something that one "Must do in order to get to the fun part". Due to this, many riders never truly learned how to do it well. The horses were flatted in a very false manner, their heads pulled to their chests, completely lacking in engagement and very hollow through their spine. This led to the fact that many were having their SI injected. There was a time when in that world, you heard people telling others to get their horses SI done as frequently as we hear barrel racers discussing hocks.
I do believe that too many people are not educated enough about joint injections. I also feel as though even fewer are properly educated about good quality leg care and conditioning. Why do leg work during the week to keep one sound when they can just go get their horse injected every six months? Most of those folks have no idea what their horse is being injected with, don't know what the joint looked like, nor know if the joint was dry, full of fluid, if the fluid was gritty/bloody. All they know is that their horse got his hocks done so he should win the barrel race this weekend. This again, I attribute to a lack of education. It scares me that even quite a few professionals, who are out winning big stuff, have no clue what to do for a horse beyond take it to the vet and say "It's not turning. Fix it!".
All of this being said, I will be the first to inject one if they need it. I don't play games with my horse's joint health. If one tells me that they're having an issue, it gets addressed. If injecting it along with the other care that it receives is the best route to take at the time, that's what I'll do. If one really needs time off, I'll give them as much time as they need. I think that people overreact to young horses being injected . A lot of people tend to believe that once you inject, you will always have to inject. I feel that this was almost proven to be true for a long time. In my mind, the reason for that is because a horse with an issue would be left and run on that bad joint until it got to the point that it crippled up. The owner finally took it to the vet, the horse was injected, came sound and started performing again. Six months later, the horse started exhibiting signs of pain again. Back to the vet, new set of injections and viola! The thing that people must realize is that due to their negligence in not having addressed the issue sooner, irreparable damage was done. As a result, yes your horse does now require bi-annual injections. This is the fault of the negligent owner, not the injection.
I'm totally ignorant, but if a horse is showing that much during the day at a show why in the world would they need to be lounged for an hour at a canter also? Wouldn't hand walking them be more effective as far as getting them out of their stall and moving around in a manner that wasn't doing more harm? Again, I'm ignorant of all things at this level of show. That and I've never been a big fan of lounging horses especially on a lounge line. If it was good for them I imagine our vets would recommend when we start legging them back up from an injury that we walk them in circles for the first 2 weeks
Also wanted to add I always love your insights.
Edited by run n rate 2015-10-22 11:28 AM
| |
| | |
  Damn Yankee
Posts: 12390
         Location: Somewhere between raising hell and Amazing Grace | I think sometimes the best way to truly know the benefit of a needed injection is to be the recipient of one. I have had spine surgery. Back in 2005. In the last ten years I have had one injection in my spine and two in my SI joint to help with maintaining everything. Not only does it help immediately it helps with the long term maintenance as well. It's not a "fix". It's an assistance to other treatments. | |
| | |
 Extreme Veteran
Posts: 456
      Location: SW MO | I also have had my back injected, along with surgery on a disc and I can say that managing the pain really helps me! If the horse has legitimate need then yes injecting is fine in my book. But other posters have said there can be multiple reasons for soreness... I think all culprits should be exhausted before treatment if possible | |
| | |
I AM being nice
Posts: 4396
        Location: MD | run n rate - 2015-10-22 11:26 AM
WrapSnap - 2015-10-22 9:11 PM
I have to say, I feel as though many of the people who are saying that we don't see as many injections in the English disciplines were obviously not either in upper level programs, or "in the know" as to what was going on.
There really isn't so much of a difference in the level and/or types of maintenance that the English horses get versus the barrel horses. If you have actual experience in both arenas, you'll get what I'm saying. You can go to any local, schooling type hunter show and watch a bunch of lesson horses packing a kid around the Short Stirrup Hunter class who's stifles are obviously shot. Maybe they have a bit of an uneven stride in the trot while hacking. Those same type horses are being loped through with little Susie at your local barrel race, being whipped on in an attempt to win the 4D in the Youth. The difference is that in the Hunter world, little Susie's trainers say nothing about the unsoundness, nor bring up joint injections. In the barrel racing world, little Susie's mom, who has never ridden a horse is her trainer and she is sitting on the fence screaming at Susie to whip harder. Susie's mom then gets on an online forum, maybe posts a video and 1,000 "internet vets" say they think that Susie's horse Spot looks very sore and that she should have his hocks checked.
While Dressage horses are often dealt with quite differently, I can guarantee you that the top show Hunters, Jumpers and 3 Day Event horses become very good friends with their vets. Not only that, how many of you have ever been to say the Winter Equestrian Festival, in Wellington, FL. Take a walk through someone's barn (only if invited, of course) and take a peek in the feed room while you're at it. That big wipe board, that's the med list. I promise you that pretty much every horse in the barn is going to be on it. Those horses get more needles than most of the horses at the NFR. It only stands to reason. We'll say that while at a multi week show, a good Hunter is showing 3 or 4 days a week. That sucker is going to be on a longe line, cantering around for at least an hour and more likely two or three before each day of showing. That sort of wear and tear on one's body dictates that they are going to be sore.
I can also tell you from personal experience that the 3 Day Event crowd are worse than barrel racers when it comes to injections. Those horses are truly the iron horses of Equestrian sport. Not only do they almost have to be a Dressage horse, they have to be adept at jumping a 1.20 meter show jump course and they have to be fit enough to gallop a cross country course, up and down terrain. Until recently, the Dressage phase of an Event was something that one "Must do in order to get to the fun part". Due to this, many riders never truly learned how to do it well. The horses were flatted in a very false manner, their heads pulled to their chests, completely lacking in engagement and very hollow through their spine. This led to the fact that many were having their SI injected. There was a time when in that world, you heard people telling others to get their horses SI done as frequently as we hear barrel racers discussing hocks.
I do believe that too many people are not educated enough about joint injections. I also feel as though even fewer are properly educated about good quality leg care and conditioning. Why do leg work during the week to keep one sound when they can just go get their horse injected every six months? Most of those folks have no idea what their horse is being injected with, don't know what the joint looked like, nor know if the joint was dry, full of fluid, if the fluid was gritty/bloody. All they know is that their horse got his hocks done so he should win the barrel race this weekend. This again, I attribute to a lack of education. It scares me that even quite a few professionals, who are out winning big stuff, have no clue what to do for a horse beyond take it to the vet and say "It's not turning. Fix it!".
All of this being said, I will be the first to inject one if they need it. I don't play games with my horse's joint health. If one tells me that they're having an issue, it gets addressed. If injecting it along with the other care that it receives is the best route to take at the time, that's what I'll do. If one really needs time off, I'll give them as much time as they need. I think that people overreact to young horses being injected . A lot of people tend to believe that once you inject, you will always have to inject. I feel that this was almost proven to be true for a long time. In my mind, the reason for that is because a horse with an issue would be left and run on that bad joint until it got to the point that it crippled up. The owner finally took it to the vet, the horse was injected, came sound and started performing again. Six months later, the horse started exhibiting signs of pain again. Back to the vet, new set of injections and viola! The thing that people must realize is that due to their negligence in not having addressed the issue sooner, irreparable damage was done. As a result, yes your horse does now require bi-annual injections. This is the fault of the negligent owner, not the injection.
I'm totally ignorant, but if a horse is showing that much during the day at a show why in the world would they need to be lounged for an hour at a canter also? Wouldn't hand walking them be more effective as far as getting them out of their stall and moving around in a manner that wasn't doing more harm? Again, I'm ignorant of all things at this level of show. That and I've never been a big fan of lounging horses especially on a lounge line. If it was good for them I imagine our vets would recommend when we start legging them back up from an injury that we walk them in circles for the first 2 weeks
Also wanted to add I always love your insights.
In the show Hunter ring, they have to be super quiet. It's not as bad now that so much emphasis has been placed upon the Handy rounds and the Hunter Derbies, but you're still way better off to have to sink your spurs into one's sides than to have to whisper the word "whoa" while on course. | |
| | |
 Balance Beam and more...
Posts: 11511
    Location: 31 lengths farms | Not exactly the same but I used to get in "spoken" to a little from the gentleman I took cutting lessons from because I didn't show up at 7 am to lope my gelding down for hours before the herd work at the reined cow shows. A) he didnt' need to be loped down and B) I dont' think it especially good for a horse to be loped for an hour in 6-8 inches of deep ground meant to slow a cow down. I'm not a big fan of fatigue training.
| |
| | |
I AM being nice
Posts: 4396
        Location: MD | run n rate - 2015-10-22 1:32 PM
Not exactly the same but I used to get in "spoken" to a little from the gentleman I took cutting lessons from because I didn't show up at 7 am to lope my gelding down for hours before the herd work at the reined cow shows. A) he didnt' need to be loped down and B) I dont' think it especially good for a horse to be loped for an hour in 6-8 inches of deep ground meant to slow a cow down. I'm not a big fan of fatigue training.
Nor am I and when I was doing the Hunters full time, I always had grooms trying to come to work for me because they knew that there would be very minimal longeing done in my barn. Unfortunately, it is however the norm in that realm. | |
| | |
  Warmblood with Wings
Posts: 27846
           Location: Florida.. | WrapSnap - 2015-10-22 12:11 AM I have to say, I feel as though many of the people who are saying that we don't see as many injections in the English disciplines were obviously not either in upper level programs, or "in the know" as to what was going on. There really isn't so much of a difference in the level and/or types of maintenance that the English horses get versus the barrel horses. If you have actual experience in both arenas, you'll get what I'm saying. You can go to any local, schooling type hunter show and watch a bunch of lesson horses packing a kid around the Short Stirrup Hunter class who's stifles are obviously shot. Maybe they have a bit of an uneven stride in the trot while hacking. Those same type horses are being loped through with little Susie at your local barrel race, being whipped on in an attempt to win the 4D in the Youth. The difference is that in the Hunter world, little Susie's trainers say nothing about the unsoundness, nor bring up joint injections. In the barrel racing world, little Susie's mom, who has never ridden a horse is her trainer and she is sitting on the fence screaming at Susie to whip harder. Susie's mom then gets on an online forum, maybe posts a video and 1,000 "internet vets" say they think that Susie's horse Spot looks very sore and that she should have his hocks checked. While Dressage horses are often dealt with quite differently, I can guarantee you that the top show Hunters, Jumpers and 3 Day Event horses become very good friends with their vets. Not only that, how many of you have ever been to say the Winter Equestrian Festival, in Wellington, FL. Take a walk through someone's barn (only if invited, of course) and take a peek in the feed room while you're at it. That big wipe board, that's the med list. I promise you that pretty much every horse in the barn is going to be on it. Those horses get more needles than most of the horses at the NFR. It only stands to reason. We'll say that while at a multi week show, a good Hunter is showing 3 or 4 days a week. That sucker is going to be on a longe line, cantering around for at least an hour and more likely two or three before each day of showing. That sort of wear and tear on one's body dictates that they are going to be sore. I can also tell you from personal experience that the 3 Day Event crowd are worse than barrel racers when it comes to injections. Those horses are truly the iron horses of Equestrian sport. Not only do they almost have to be a Dressage horse, they have to be adept at jumping a 1.20 meter show jump course and they have to be fit enough to gallop a cross country course, up and down terrain. Until recently, the Dressage phase of an Event was something that one "Must do in order to get to the fun part". Due to this, many riders never truly learned how to do it well. The horses were flatted in a very false manner, their heads pulled to their chests, completely lacking in engagement and very hollow through their spine. This led to the fact that many were having their SI injected. There was a time when in that world, you heard people telling others to get their horses SI done as frequently as we hear barrel racers discussing hocks. I do believe that too many people are not educated enough about joint injections. I also feel as though even fewer are properly educated about good quality leg care and conditioning. Why do leg work during the week to keep one sound when they can just go get their horse injected every six months? Most of those folks have no idea what their horse is being injected with, don't know what the joint looked like, nor know if the joint was dry, full of fluid, if the fluid was gritty/bloody. All they know is that their horse got his hocks done so he should win the barrel race this weekend. This again, I attribute to a lack of education. It scares me that even quite a few professionals, who are out winning big stuff, have no clue what to do for a horse beyond take it to the vet and say "It's not turning. Fix it!". All of this being said, I will be the first to inject one if they need it. I don't play games with my horse's joint health. If one tells me that they're having an issue, it gets addressed. If injecting it along with the other care that it receives is the best route to take at the time, that's what I'll do. If one really needs time off, I'll give them as much time as they need. I think that people overreact to young horses being injected . A lot of people tend to believe that once you inject, you will always have to inject. I feel that this was almost proven to be true for a long time. In my mind, the reason for that is because a horse with an issue would be left and run on that bad joint until it got to the point that it crippled up. The owner finally took it to the vet, the horse was injected, came sound and started performing again. Six months later, the horse started exhibiting signs of pain again. Back to the vet, new set of injections and viola! The thing that people must realize is that due to their negligence in not having addressed the issue sooner, irreparable damage was done. As a result, yes your horse does now require bi-annual injections. This is the fault of the negligent owner, not the injection. It is not as normal for injections to all the differant joints as it is to barrel racers. I had a show barn in wellington for many years . and yes been "In the know " and upper level.. yes we did alot of stuff but to say it compares I disagree on..Im not one to name people not my style but I can say "all the top " didnt inject as much as some of the things I have seen with other disciplines....we injected when needed.. we gave time off and rode other mounts when needed , we tried holistic when needed and other therapies, we were best friends with our vets.. but we werent so fast to put a needle in their joint as I have seen in other events.. thats just how I see it.. we did alot of things I wont disagree on that .. we all have our opinions though..
Edited by Bibliafarm 2015-10-22 3:02 PM
| |
| | |
I AM being nice
Posts: 4396
        Location: MD | Bibliafarm - 2015-10-22 2:59 PM
WrapSnap - 2015-10-22 12:11 AM I have to say, I feel as though many of the people who are saying that we don't see as many injections in the English disciplines were obviously not either in upper level programs, or "in the know" as to what was going on. There really isn't so much of a difference in the level and/or types of maintenance that the English horses get versus the barrel horses. If you have actual experience in both arenas, you'll get what I'm saying. You can go to any local, schooling type hunter show and watch a bunch of lesson horses packing a kid around the Short Stirrup Hunter class who's stifles are obviously shot. Maybe they have a bit of an uneven stride in the trot while hacking. Those same type horses are being loped through with little Susie at your local barrel race, being whipped on in an attempt to win the 4D in the Youth. The difference is that in the Hunter world, little Susie's trainers say nothing about the unsoundness, nor bring up joint injections. In the barrel racing world, little Susie's mom, who has never ridden a horse is her trainer and she is sitting on the fence screaming at Susie to whip harder. Susie's mom then gets on an online forum, maybe posts a video and 1,000 "internet vets" say they think that Susie's horse Spot looks very sore and that she should have his hocks checked. While Dressage horses are often dealt with quite differently, I can guarantee you that the top show Hunters, Jumpers and 3 Day Event horses become very good friends with their vets. Not only that, how many of you have ever been to say the Winter Equestrian Festival, in Wellington, FL. Take a walk through someone's barn (only if invited, of course) and take a peek in the feed room while you're at it. That big wipe board, that's the med list. I promise you that pretty much every horse in the barn is going to be on it. Those horses get more needles than most of the horses at the NFR. It only stands to reason. We'll say that while at a multi week show, a good Hunter is showing 3 or 4 days a week. That sucker is going to be on a longe line, cantering around for at least an hour and more likely two or three before each day of showing. That sort of wear and tear on one's body dictates that they are going to be sore. I can also tell you from personal experience that the 3 Day Event crowd are worse than barrel racers when it comes to injections. Those horses are truly the iron horses of Equestrian sport. Not only do they almost have to be a Dressage horse, they have to be adept at jumping a 1.20 meter show jump course and they have to be fit enough to gallop a cross country course, up and down terrain. Until recently, the Dressage phase of an Event was something that one "Must do in order to get to the fun part". Due to this, many riders never truly learned how to do it well. The horses were flatted in a very false manner, their heads pulled to their chests, completely lacking in engagement and very hollow through their spine. This led to the fact that many were having their SI injected. There was a time when in that world, you heard people telling others to get their horses SI done as frequently as we hear barrel racers discussing hocks. I do believe that too many people are not educated enough about joint injections. I also feel as though even fewer are properly educated about good quality leg care and conditioning. Why do leg work during the week to keep one sound when they can just go get their horse injected every six months? Most of those folks have no idea what their horse is being injected with, don't know what the joint looked like, nor know if the joint was dry, full of fluid, if the fluid was gritty/bloody. All they know is that their horse got his hocks done so he should win the barrel race this weekend. This again, I attribute to a lack of education. It scares me that even quite a few professionals, who are out winning big stuff, have no clue what to do for a horse beyond take it to the vet and say "It's not turning. Fix it!". All of this being said, I will be the first to inject one if they need it. I don't play games with my horse's joint health. If one tells me that they're having an issue, it gets addressed. If injecting it along with the other care that it receives is the best route to take at the time, that's what I'll do. If one really needs time off, I'll give them as much time as they need. I think that people overreact to young horses being injected . A lot of people tend to believe that once you inject, you will always have to inject. I feel that this was almost proven to be true for a long time. In my mind, the reason for that is because a horse with an issue would be left and run on that bad joint until it got to the point that it crippled up. The owner finally took it to the vet, the horse was injected, came sound and started performing again. Six months later, the horse started exhibiting signs of pain again. Back to the vet, new set of injections and viola! The thing that people must realize is that due to their negligence in not having addressed the issue sooner, irreparable damage was done. As a result, yes your horse does now require bi-annual injections. This is the fault of the negligent owner, not the injection. It is not as normal for injections to all the differant joints as it is to barrel racers. I had a show barn in wellington for many years . and yes been "In the know " and upper level.. yes we did alot of stuff but to say it compares I disagree on..Im not one to name people not my style but I can say "all the top " didnt inject as much as some of the things I have seen with other disciplines....we injected when needed.. we gave time off and rode other mounts when needed , we tried holistic when needed and other therapies, we were best friends with our vets.. but we werent so fast to put a needle in their joint as I have seen in other events.. thats just how I see it.. we did alot of things I wont disagree on that .. we all have our opinions though..
This is why I said "many of the people". I know that you are an exception and have been at the top levels as a professional. You are unfortunately one of the rare few who put your horses' welfare above a clients' demands. | |
| | |
  Warmblood with Wings
Posts: 27846
           Location: Florida.. | Ok I am sorry I got a defensive lol.. we do keep our horses comfortable and certainly not aganist injecting.. or maybe I just closed my eyes to some .. it just appears that some inject blindly for any issue I guess was what was trying to say.. in BR.. without knowing why or what it does etc.. :) I think some dont realize that it will wear down their joints later on in years.. so to have it done sparingly as a only when needed basis is best but i do feel its a necessary evil when needed and all other avenues have been taken.
Edited by Bibliafarm 2015-10-22 3:30 PM
| |
| | |
 Not Afraid to Work
Posts: 4717
    
| As far as the jumper vs barrel controversy, I think a lot of that depends intirely on the barn and crowd. I have been in the "know" in very high barrel barns and very high 3 day eventing barns. I have noticed the horses seem to be getting similar treatments. Before chiro was big, once one chiro's everyone did. once one used an equine dentist, everyone did. When one had hock injections, everyone started injecting. They all mysteriously started having similar problems or treatments.
Ive seen it on the other side of the spectrum too, where they are more hesitant to inject or do more invasive procedures so that barn/group relied on less invasive measures. Maybe massage or a supplement. Think about ulcers, no one ever mentioned ulcers but now they are the first thing people treat for. Saddle fit is the same way. Many of us competed in 800-1000 billy cooks, martha joseys, sharon camarillos, etc.. now its a trend to buy 8" gullets, flex trees, treeless...
I am not saying that education and treatments arent improving which could be a part of this but my point is that people seem to follow trends, especially from their peers around them. if jo, sam and katie all had a horse struggling to engage his haunches and injections helped well then john might just inject without proper diagnosing equipment.
People forget that treatment shouldnt be based on reviews... yes a product may work for one but not the other. I am not sure if my point even came across, it makes sense in my head  | |
| | |
The Advice Guru
Posts: 6419
     
| Bibliafarm - 2015-10-22 3:26 PM
Ok I am sorry I got a defensive lol.. we do keep our horses comfortable and certainly not aganist injecting.. or maybe I just closed my eyes to some .. it just appears that some inject blindly for any issue I guess was what was trying to say.. in BR.. without knowing why or what it does etc.. :) I think some dont realize that it will wear down their joints later on in years.. so to have it done sparingly as a only when needed basis is best but i do feel its a necessary evil when needed and all other avenues have been taken.
Not all injections "will wear down joints". This is where people need to do their research.
The best thing I ever did was buy an equine pharmacology text book, now I have two, this way I can verify the information in both, have the most current that is being taught in vet school, and can understand my vet.
Depo, betamethasone, cortico steroids have all been proven to degenerate a joint long term.
Trimisclione, is the one steroid that the studies have shown it has regenerated carlilage in the joints.
HA has been shown to preserve the joint | |
| |
|