Same question!! There's only a $5 difference between those and Stall Skins so I would also like opinions as I'm ordering one soon! ETA: Just watched this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-_l9EDMr_A and although the Stall Skins say "thicker isn't always better" I think I may go with the Stall Savers due to the durability. I got a free sample of it in the mail and it's pretty thick stuff