I tried a couple Charmayne James saddles over the weekend. When I went back to return the Martin, the store had a Reinsman CJ wide fit so I figured I would see if it fit. I also got a hold of a used Cactus CJ, regular tree to compare the two. The first set of pictures is the wide Reinsman and the second set is the Cactus regular. I am was able to ride in the Cactus so I also including sweat mark pictures. Additionally, I am including pictures of how each saddle measures. I contacted Reinsman and was told the wide is a 7" gullet.
Posted 2018-12-18 9:44 AM Subject: RE: Saddle Fit Help - Continued
Expert
Posts: 5290
I like the cactus fit better. Looks more level. Reinsman does use the same tree as the cactus, just different saddle maker. I have a cactus wide CJ and the Reinsman CJ wide. Both same tree. Fit the same! I sure like how the cactus looks on your horse
Posted 2018-12-18 9:56 AM Subject: RE: Saddle Fit Help - Continued
Georgia Peach
Posts: 8338 Location: Georgia
Thank yall! Thats what I was thinking also, just wanted to confirm. While I know the Cactus may not be exactly perfect I think it's pretty close to where we need to be for now. When I rode in it I felt comfortable and didnt feel like I was being thrown forward. I will just have to get used to a little flatter seat than I am used to. But obviously that is not a deal breaker. I can adapt. I'm going to check her today for any soreness just to be sure. I already found a Cactus on facebook I want to buy so I was hoping you guys liked the fit lol.
Saddle Fit Help - Continued
