Log in to my account Barrel Horse World
Come on in Folks on-line

Today is

You are logged in as a guest. Logon or register an account to access more features.


Starting a colt in a german or running martingale

Jump to page :
Last activity 2015-10-09 11:11 PM
36 replies, 9291 views

View previous thread :: View next thread
   General Discussion -> Barrel Talk
Refresh
 
Speedy Buckeye Girl
Reg. Jun 2010
Posted 2015-10-06 12:22 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Elite Veteran


Posts: 878
500100100100252525
Location: "...way down south in the Everglades..."
To OP - no, never have, never will. Have I used one? Yes, absolutely, but in a horse that already is broke with the basics and I use it as a training aid and not a crutch.

To BarrelHorseUSA - George Morris is certainly not a barrel trainer or rider, but I will guarantee that if you had the opportunity of attending one of his clinics you would learn something that would transfer over to yes, even barrel racing. That said, the rest of your post I couldn't agree more with.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
oija
Reg. Feb 2012
Posted 2015-10-07 11:56 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Expert


Posts: 3782
20001000500100100252525
Location: Gainesville, TX
BARRELHORSE USA - 2015-10-05 11:14 PM

streakysox - 2015-10-05 1:31 PM

GLP - 2015-10-05 11:22 AM

oija - 2015-10-05 11:18 AM

BARRELHORSE USA - 2015-10-05 1:17 AM The problem with any type of martingale or tie down is the horse owner // trainer misunderstanding how to use one. They are not to tie a horses head down with face perpendicular to the ground like the ones you see all the time in the arena .. German martingales have adjustment holes to set at correct length all the others are dependent on rider having soft hands and knowing the purpose of the martingale .... tie downers just want to suck that head down between old horses legs thinking this gives them control of their horse .. A running horse needs to stick his nose out to run or use his head for balance when making a turn and there is no such thing as a horse being collected while running ... remember the old saying... A HORSE WILL FOLLOW HIS NOSE .... Pay attention to the top dawgs and how they use them ... they are used loosely with enough slack so a horse bumps his nose if his jaw line gets above his withers .... and a perfect fit is when horse learns they can use it for head balance making their turns. Next to barrel racers and ropers the worst abusers are race track exercise riders .. they will have horses chin pressed against chest while doing his weekly training gallops which is comfortable rocking chair ride for the exercise rider and is Ok with horse because he is learning how to run slow instead of working at full stride length. Trainers and owners seem to be perfectly dumb how their horse won their first couple of races and then will lose their explosive speed due to how they are being exercised ... this is when they start using drugs, miracle supplements and joint injections .. sound familiar?? Barrel racing and track racing has one similarity ... both are controlled stampedes with crazy eyed fearless riders trying to kill themselves .... lol ..

Absolutely a horse can be collected while running. You can teach the horse to do it themselves naturally or you can carry them (much harder to do and a bad idea). Tucking the horse's nose in IS NOT COLLECTION. And collection is not just a shorter stride. Most newbies, and I was one of them, believe that collection starts with their nose. It doesn't. It begins in their hind end.  Collection involves a horse driving with their hind end and then lightening their front end. When you see one just running hell for leather in a straight line you might think its impossible to have one collect themselves but see a well trained horse (even with head up--NOT STARGAZING) correctly gather for a barrel turn (without dropping their shoulder or running past), martingale or no martingale, and you will see a horse correctly using collection AT A RUN.  

"you don't try to pull a horse's head down, but rather push it down (from the leg). Riding a horse from back to front, leg to hand is the classical and proper way to help a horse find self-carriage. . . . When horses find their balance and center under the rider, their head will find its proper position naturally." --adapted from George Morris







This is EXACTLY what I am saying. Horses running flat out ARE not collected. Yes we use tie downs on aour butt dragging horses to balance on. Thanks Barrelhorse.





HELLO ALL MY FRIENDS ON BHW ...
meet GEORGE MORRIS and follow his training tips at your next BARREL JUMPING EVENT ....
http://www.ghmclinics.com/

NOW DON'T GET TOO EXCITED WITH ENTHUSIASM AS YOU LISTEN TO GEORGE...
https://youtu.be/eGk7aAJdCRY

BREAKING NEWS ...!!!
OWNERS ACCUSED OF CHEATING BY RUNNING A COLLECTED HORSE
AT BELMONT PARK RACE COURSE !!...
OWNERS: NYC MAFIA
https://youtu.be/_uQOchrK7NA

Have a NICE LAUGH ..

Good horsemanship is good horsemanship. And I don't care if you are jumping, doing dressage, reining, or barrel racing, the mechanics and physics of a horse's body are the same. A horse working with power from the hind end is prized in pretty much any discipline. We breed them with slightly different conformations to help them accomplish certain aspects of their tasks better, but the basics are the basics. The basics of defense for soccer and basketball have some key differences, and they have some key similarities, like blocking. One sport may use their hands and the other their feet but getting in front of the ball and stopping scoring are shared. I don't care if you are jumping or barrel racing, collection and working off the hind end are good basics. A collected, balanced horse will simply turn better. You may see them more flat out on the run home, but they collect to turn and smooth, clean turns are what separates barrel racing from track racing. COLLECTION IS USED. I challenge you to go to any solid trainer's clinic and hear them encourage a front heavy, uncollected horse. They will all say you want the horse to gather themselves, shorten their stride, lift their shoulder, balance themselves, and work from their hind end around the barrel. And whaddya know but ol Georgie boy says it too. Hmmm might be something to it.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
streakysox
Reg. Jul 2008
Posted 2015-10-08 11:39 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Take a Picture


Posts: 12837
50005000200050010010010025
Just got my barrel horse news. On the cover, the 1D winner of the Colonial Nationals is using a tiedown. It happens to be a war bonnet but none the less a tie down. It seems that most of the D winners had tie downs.


Low and behold, in the thread about the peewee rider someone posted a video of Lance Graves. He is using a running martingale!e on the young horse he is riding.

I think there might be something to this.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
WrapSnap
Reg. Dec 2010
Posted 2015-10-09 12:25 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


I AM being nice


Posts: 4396
20002000100100100252525
Location: MD
A few years back, I posted a video of myself on a 4 yr old who had about 75 days under saddle on this forum. I was riding her in a loosely adjusted German martingale and the number of people who took offense to the use of such equipment on a horse of that age and experience was rather large.

I do believe I shall share it again :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7L07jNHv_mA
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Itsme
Reg. Jul 2013
Posted 2015-10-09 12:40 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


Expert


Posts: 1561
10005002525
The lady I know that starts her colts in a running martingale has multiple horses that won futurities and some in their 20s running hard and a 16yo that won some jackpots and a couple rodeos this year.

I would take her opinion of different things work for different people and horses vs a random person on here that is very narrow minded and says nope, never, no benefit at all...
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Itsme
Reg. Jul 2013
Posted 2015-10-09 12:46 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


Expert


Posts: 1561
10005002525
WrapSnap - 2015-10-09 12:25 AM

A few years back, I posted a video of myself on a 4 yr old who had about 75 days under saddle on this forum. I was riding her in a loosely adjusted German martingale and the number of people who took offense to the use of such equipment on a horse of that age and experience was rather large.

I do believe I shall share it again :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7L07jNHv_mA

How did that horse turn out?
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
WrapSnap
Reg. Dec 2010
Posted 2015-10-09 12:53 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


I AM being nice


Posts: 4396
20002000100100100252525
Location: MD
Itsme - 2015-10-09 12:46 AM

WrapSnap - 2015-10-09 12:25 AM

A few years back, I posted a video of myself on a 4 yr old who had about 75 days under saddle on this forum. I was riding her in a loosely adjusted German martingale and the number of people who took offense to the use of such equipment on a horse of that age and experience was rather large.

I do believe I shall share it again :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7L07jNHv_mA

How did that horse turn out?

She ended up being a nice enough local 2D horse. Here she is as a 5 yr old with a youth rider

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLghBX221H0

and interestingly enough, still in the German martingale. lol
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Itsme
Reg. Jul 2013
Posted 2015-10-09 1:01 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


Expert


Posts: 1561
10005002525
Right on, cool little horse!
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
streakysox
Reg. Jul 2008
Posted 2015-10-09 7:57 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Take a Picture


Posts: 12837
50005000200050010010010025
WrapSnap - 2015-10-09 12:53 AM

Itsme - 2015-10-09 12:46 AM

WrapSnap - 2015-10-09 12:25 AM

A few years back, I posted a video of myself on a 4 yr old who had about 75 days under saddle on this forum. I was riding her in a loosely adjusted German martingale and the number of people who took offense to the use of such equipment on a horse of that age and experience was rather large.

I do believe I shall share it again :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7L07jNHv_mA

How did that horse turn out?

She ended up being a nice enough local 2D horse. Here she is as a 5 yr old with a youth rider

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLghBX221H0

and interestingly enough, still in the German martingale. lol

This is my 3 year old. Her first run in a tie down (exh). Trainer had worked her quite a bit at home but you have to get out to see how they will do away from the house. Trainer is on the horse.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hy_uB7OM69Q

This is my paint in my avatar. APHA World Show 2013. Trainer running with a German Martingale. You use what works. This horse was 10 at the time. This horse has a tremendous handle on him, super broke.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYhRCoi0U-A

↑ Top ↓ Bottom
MS2011
Reg. Mar 2005
Posted 2015-10-09 8:33 AM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Own It and Move On


20002000100100100100
Location: The edge of no where
cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-04 11:38 PM
Itsme - 2015-10-04 4:43 PM So, 99% on here say to train them "correctly" but 95% run in a tie down to correct a training issue...
Hey man I don't like tie downs either. If the horse is trained and ridden right there is no use for them. I feel the same way with standing martingales in the hunter world.
So - according to your logic - Stingray isn't trained correctly?   There's a very long list of good ones that run in tie downs.  Before you chunk everyone under the bus, you might want to study WHY tie downs are sometimes very helpful in a timed event.  The fact that you're comparing it to a standing martingale on a hunter is laughable and really shows how poorly you understand the differnce in the way the horses use their bodies.   A correctly adjusted tie down, bonnet, and sometimes a german martingale will help some horses be a tick quicker....it isn't that they can't perform without one, but can do it better with a little help.

Yes - I've learned a TON from George Morris and have nothing but respect for him.  I've also learned from some top barrel horse trainers as well....no one person is right ALL the time.  You have to have enough sense not to just read out of a book and spout theories - get out and do it.   WrapSnap - love watching your horses go.  After coming from a hunter/jumper background, a lot of what you do makes great sense to me. 


On young horses - it's all about the hands starting them.  There are tools available, but you've got to have great hands.  Someone with good hands can ride a horse in just about anything.



 

Edited by MS2011 2015-10-09 8:39 AM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
GLP
Reg. Oct 2013
Posted 2015-10-09 4:20 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


I just read the headlines


Posts: 4483
20002000100100100100252525
Itsme - 2015-10-09 12:40 AM

The lady I know that starts her colts in a running martingale has multiple horses that won futurities and some in their 20s running hard and a 16yo that won some jackpots and a couple rodeos this year.

I would take her opinion of different things work for different people and horses vs a random person on here that is very narrow minded and says nope, never, no benefit at all...

Then why did you ask? Everyone has a little different approach and opinion. Just because they may not match up with your trainer/mentor doesn't mean they are wrong or narrow minded to have a different approach/method. I said nope because that was not how I was taught to start one and the people I admired the most also didn't start a colt in one from day one. It doesn't mean that if someone chooses to start one that way, I think they are wrong, it just means that is not how I would do it.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
NJJ
Reg. Jul 2006
Posted 2015-10-09 4:42 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


Military family

Fact Checker


Posts: 16572
50005000500010005002525
Location: Displaced Iowegian
GLP - 2015-10-09 4:20 PM
Itsme - 2015-10-09 12:40 AM The lady I know that starts her colts in a running martingale has multiple horses that won futurities and some in their 20s running hard and a 16yo that won some jackpots and a couple rodeos this year. I would take her opinion of different things work for different people and horses vs a random person on here that is very narrow minded and says nope, never, no benefit at all...
Then why did you ask? Everyone has a little different approach and opinion. Just because they may not match up with your trainer/mentor doesn't mean they are wrong or narrow minded to have a different approach/method. I said nope because that was not how I was taught to start one and the people I admired the most also didn't start a colt in one from day one. It doesn't mean that if someone chooses to start one that way, I think they are wrong, it just means that is not how I would do it.

UMMMM....I don't think that he/she posed the question.... 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
cavyrunsbarrels
Reg. Dec 2010
Posted 2015-10-09 4:55 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


Red Bull Agressive


Posts: 5981
5000500100100100100252525
Location: North Dakota
MS2011 - 2015-10-09 8:33 AM
cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-04 11:38 PM
Itsme - 2015-10-04 4:43 PM So, 99% on here say to train them "correctly" but 95% run in a tie down to correct a training issue...
Hey man I don't like tie downs either. If the horse is trained and ridden right there is no use for them. I feel the same way with standing martingales in the hunter world.
So - according to your logic - Stingray isn't trained correctly?   There's a very long list of good ones that run in tie downs.  Before you chunk everyone under the bus, you might want to study WHY tie downs are sometimes very helpful in a timed event.  The fact that you're comparing it to a standing martingale on a hunter is laughable and really shows how poorly you understand the differnce in the way the horses use their bodies.   A correctly adjusted tie down, bonnet, and sometimes a german martingale will help some horses be a tick quicker....it isn't that they can't perform without one, but can do it better with a little help.



Yes - I've learned a TON from George Morris and have nothing but respect for him.  I've also learned from some top barrel horse trainers as well....no one person is right ALL the time.  You have to have enough sense not to just read out of a book and spout theories - get out and do it.   WrapSnap - love watching your horses go.  After coming from a hunter/jumper background, a lot of what you do makes great sense to me. 




On young horses - it's all about the hands starting them.  There are tools available, but you've got to have great hands.  Someone with good hands can ride a horse in just about anything.







 

I'll stand by my statement. A standing martingale both tie a horse's nose to the girth. While a hunter and a barrel horse are vastly different creatures, the mechanics of the strap do not change. It prevents a horse's head from going up beyond a certain point. If they hit the end of it they can either release the pressure by putting their head down or learn to brace against it. It has been my experience that if your horse is throwing its head up frequently enough that you feel the need to strap it down, then you have another issue going on. Typically, from what I have witnessed talking to riders and watching thousands of barrel runs, mounted shooting, etc. there are a LOT of riders that flop around and have very rough hands and very strong bits and when their horse objects to having their face rammed on, peoples' answer is to put a tie down on rather than fix the issue. Or people put them on for literally no reason, other than they think they are part of the "uniform". Or the horse has some other pain issue going on. But perhaps there is another advantage some people like Sherry (whom I do respect) feel they get from using a tie down on their horses.

It is my personal opinion based only on my training and experiences that horse and rider can function on an optimal level without ever using any sort of tie down, martingale, etc. I certainly never have used any sort of training aid to ride. It is also my opinion that while I am not a fan, and really do not see a use for them, a properly fitted tie down (etc) is not inherently harmful nor does it mean the rider is totally incompetent. This is a quote from an article on the subject that I quite liked. 
"From a ridden point of view, there is no doubt that rider training falls down badly. We do not meet a lot of people who truly know how to ride a horse (without gimmicks) and to have it going so as to constantly improve the top line. Those that cannot do it should then use whatever available gimmick that can at least still build the correct muscle development, until such time as they do know how to ride it. Either that or stay right away from the mouth of the horse."
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
WrapSnap
Reg. Dec 2010
Posted 2015-10-09 8:27 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


I AM being nice


Posts: 4396
20002000100100100252525
Location: MD
cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-09 4:55 PM

MS2011 - 2015-10-09 8:33 AM
cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-04 11:38 PM
Itsme - 2015-10-04 4:43 PM So, 99% on here say to train them "correctly" but 95% run in a tie down to correct a training issue...
Hey man I don't like tie downs either. If the horse is trained and ridden right there is no use for them. I feel the same way with standing martingales in the hunter world.
So - according to your logic - Stingray isn't trained correctly?   There's a very long list of good ones that run in tie downs.  Before you chunk everyone under the bus, you might want to study WHY tie downs are sometimes very helpful in a timed event.  The fact that you're comparing it to a standing martingale on a hunter is laughable and really shows how poorly you understand the differnce in the way the horses use their bodies.   A correctly adjusted tie down, bonnet, and sometimes a german martingale will help some horses be a tick quicker....it isn't that they can't perform without one, but can do it better with a little help.



Yes - I've learned a TON from George Morris and have nothing but respect for him.  I've also learned from some top barrel horse trainers as well....no one person is right ALL the time.  You have to have enough sense not to just read out of a book and spout theories - get out and do it.   WrapSnap - love watching your horses go.  After coming from a hunter/jumper background, a lot of what you do makes great sense to me. 




On young horses - it's all about the hands starting them.  There are tools available, but you've got to have great hands.  Someone with good hands can ride a horse in just about anything.







 

I'll stand by my statement. A standing martingale both tie a horse's nose to the girth. While a hunter and a barrel horse are vastly different creatures, the mechanics of the strap do not change. It prevents a horse's head from going up beyond a certain point. If they hit the end of it they can either release the pressure by putting their head down or learn to brace against it. It has been my experience that if your horse is throwing its head up frequently enough that you feel the need to strap it down, then you have another issue going on. Typically, from what I have witnessed talking to riders and watching thousands of barrel runs, mounted shooting, etc. there are a LOT of riders that flop around and have very rough hands and very strong bits and when their horse objects to having their face rammed on, peoples' answer is to put a tie down on rather than fix the issue. Or people put them on for literally no reason, other than they think they are part of the "uniform". Or the horse has some other pain issue going on. But perhaps there is another advantage some people like Sherry (whom I do respect) feel they get from using a tie down on their horses.

It is my personal opinion based only on my training and experiences that horse and rider can function on an optimal level without ever using any sort of tie down, martingale, etc. I certainly never have used any sort of training aid to ride. It is also my opinion that while I am not a fan, and really do not see a use for them, a properly fitted tie down (etc) is not inherently harmful nor does it mean the rider is totally incompetent. This is a quote from an article on the subject that I quite liked. 
"From a ridden point of view, there is no doubt that rider training falls down badly. We do not meet a lot of people who truly know how to ride a horse (without gimmicks) and to have it going so as to constantly improve the top line. Those that cannot do it should then use whatever available gimmick that can at least still build the correct muscle development, until such time as they do know how to ride it. Either that or stay right away from the mouth of the horse."

Are you not the person who was asking all sorts of questions about a possible bit to help with a horse who got a bit too hot, forward and unresponsive not all too long ago.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
streakysox
Reg. Jul 2008
Posted 2015-10-09 10:25 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Take a Picture


Posts: 12837
50005000200050010010010025
Instead of running down those who use tie downs and martingales, you need to look at the people who consistently win. What are they doing that works? Just because someone is winning with a tie down on the horse certainly does not mean their horse is not broke. This came from Martha Josey...if you don't make changes once in awhile you become stagnant. I was at the western store one day and we were discussing a clinic.

I used to train all of my horses but I don't have time now, plus my trainer can do more in a few weeks than I can in a few months. I have been riding for over 60 years and I don't know everything there is to know about horses or training. I am sure that most of you don't know everything there is to know but you need to watch other people, especially those winning, I am sure that it will broaden your horizons. If that makes you mad then you do know everything you will ever learn.


Edited by streakysox 2015-10-09 10:28 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Tdove
Reg. Apr 2015
Posted 2015-10-09 10:26 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale



Elite Veteran


Posts: 851
5001001001002525
Location: West Texas
I will say this. There are two common themes i hear a lot.

1. You need to use this bit or this piece of equipment for the proper response in your horse. Use this bit to this and that equipment to do that and this drill to get them to do so and so, etc...

2. Using this equipment or that equipment means you do not know how to use your hands effectively without the gimmicky equipment. You should be able to do anything in a smooth snaffle if you are a real horsemen.

Both of those are incorrect as a whole. I guarantee you, in any discipline.


The 3rd thing I'll throw out there is use soft hands and ask the horse. Don't force it on the horse, let the horse tell you how to be a better rider and so on natural horsemen blah blah blah.

I've often wondered and seen the question asked, "what makes a good rider or trainer?". I'll sum it up by saying, To everything, there is a season, and a time to every purpose....

Edited by Tdove 2015-10-09 10:33 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
cavyrunsbarrels
Reg. Dec 2010
Posted 2015-10-09 11:11 PM
Subject: RE: Starting a colt in a german or running martingale


Red Bull Agressive


Posts: 5981
5000500100100100100252525
Location: North Dakota
WrapSnap - 2015-10-09 8:27 PM
cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-09 4:55 PM
MS2011 - 2015-10-09 8:33 AM
cavyrunsbarrels - 2015-10-04 11:38 PM
Itsme - 2015-10-04 4:43 PM So, 99% on here say to train them "correctly" but 95% run in a tie down to correct a training issue...
Hey man I don't like tie downs either. If the horse is trained and ridden right there is no use for them. I feel the same way with standing martingales in the hunter world.
So - according to your logic - Stingray isn't trained correctly?   There's a very long list of good ones that run in tie downs.  Before you chunk everyone under the bus, you might want to study WHY tie downs are sometimes very helpful in a timed event.  The fact that you're comparing it to a standing martingale on a hunter is laughable and really shows how poorly you understand the differnce in the way the horses use their bodies.   A correctly adjusted tie down, bonnet, and sometimes a german martingale will help some horses be a tick quicker....it isn't that they can't perform without one, but can do it better with a little help.



Yes - I've learned a TON from George Morris and have nothing but respect for him.  I've also learned from some top barrel horse trainers as well....no one person is right ALL the time.  You have to have enough sense not to just read out of a book and spout theories - get out and do it.   WrapSnap - love watching your horses go.  After coming from a hunter/jumper background, a lot of what you do makes great sense to me. 




On young horses - it's all about the hands starting them.  There are tools available, but you've got to have great hands.  Someone with good hands can ride a horse in just about anything.







 
I'll stand by my statement. A standing martingale both tie a horse's nose to the girth. While a hunter and a barrel horse are vastly different creatures, the mechanics of the strap do not change. It prevents a horse's head from going up beyond a certain point. If they hit the end of it they can either release the pressure by putting their head down or learn to brace against it. It has been my experience that if your horse is throwing its head up frequently enough that you feel the need to strap it down, then you have another issue going on. Typically, from what I have witnessed talking to riders and watching thousands of barrel runs, mounted shooting, etc. there are a LOT of riders that flop around and have very rough hands and very strong bits and when their horse objects to having their face rammed on, peoples' answer is to put a tie down on rather than fix the issue. Or people put them on for literally no reason, other than they think they are part of the "uniform". Or the horse has some other pain issue going on. But perhaps there is another advantage some people like Sherry (whom I do respect) feel they get from using a tie down on their horses.



It is my personal opinion based only on my training and experiences that horse and rider can function on an optimal level without ever using any sort of tie down, martingale, etc. I certainly never have used any sort of training aid to ride. It is also my opinion that while I am not a fan, and really do not see a use for them, a properly fitted tie down (etc) is not inherently harmful nor does it mean the rider is totally incompetent. This is a quote from an article on the subject that I quite liked. 
"From a ridden point of view, there is no doubt that rider training falls down badly. We do not meet a lot of people who truly know how to ride a horse (without gimmicks) and to have it going so as to constantly improve the top line. Those that cannot do it should then use whatever available gimmick that can at least still build the correct muscle development, until such time as they do know how to ride it. Either that or stay right away from the mouth of the horse."
Are you not the person who was asking all sorts of questions about a possible bit to help with a horse who got a bit too hot, forward and unresponsive not all too long ago.

You're right, I did ask one question on that matter. IMO bits to some degree are another ball of wax. To me they don't fit in the category of gadget (although there are gimmicky bits and downright cruel bits). I love snaffles but am not one that believes that if you don't ride in a french link eggbutt snaffle you're wrong. In regards to that situation, I will go back to the quote I inserted in my last post. That horse is one I was having an issue with that I could not fix in a snaffle. I'm positive that it could be done but I was not good enough to do it. So for a short period I employed the use of a slightly stronger bit to help me achieve what I wanted. I never would have taken this horse out of a snaffle, but he was ridden in a stronger bit before I got him. When I tried stepping down to a snaffle, he wasn't ready. A few rides in a slightly stronger bit are a stepping stone to getting back to a snaffle. And he's making good progress. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Jump to page :
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread
 

© Copyright 2002- BarrelHorseWorld.com All rights reserved including digital rights

Support - Contact / Log in to my account


Working Truck World Working Horse World Cargo Trailer World Horse Trailer World Roping Horse World
'
Registered to: Barrel Horse World
(Delete all cookies set by this site)
Running MegaBBS ASP Forum Software
© 2002-2025 PD9 Software