Too many choices

I don't know about C.A.'s cinch but I do like the shoulder relief cinch that I bought. I have used roper cinches & I like them to.

I have only used the shoulder relief cinch and none of the others listed. My horses love it and so do I

Shoulder relief cinch is highly recommended.  I have a round shortbacked horse--the saddle wants to roll unless I cut him in two and it also scooches forward.  Got a fleece shoulder relief cinch for christmas and the saddle stays put without having to over tighten.  I was amazed.

I have the felt shoulder relief cinch and I love it! I previously had trouble with my saddle slipping forward but this cinch help keeps it in place.