Does anyone have a deb sibley made by honey creek saddles? I run in a panther creek deb sibley and love it but my mom is needing a new saddle and shes either looking for a deb sibley or a caldwell. (deb sibley is significanly cheaper then a caldwell which is why its the winner) But know that weve been looking we noticed they are being made by honey creek and not panther creek. So looking for reviews on the new maker in case she cant find one used and decides to just get one new.

I have two Deb Sibley saddles both made by Panther Canyon.  One was custom ordered new and the other I bought used. (and love them both!).  You can contact Deb Sibley directly on Facebook and thru her dealers. https://www.facebook.com/Debra-Sibley-New-Barrel-Saddles-in-conjunction-with-BarNunn-Barrel-Horses-599929973693779/

There are also Used Debra Sibley saddle sites that offer nice used saddles.

I did ask on her used page but was just wondering if anyone had a personal experience with the new brand. I have a panther canyon that was bought used. And I love the saddle

Bumping before she orders one

I ordered directly from Deb and it is a Honey Creek and couldn't ask for better service.  The only thing is I wish the quality of the leather was a little better.

How does it compare to the panther canyon version leather wise?

This is my first, so I don't have anything to compare it to.  But, I did hear that now you can opt for a Herman Oak leather.  When I get another, if this is true, I will get the better leather.  Hit Deb up on facebook, she will be glad to talk with you about it.  Then you'll get it direct.