I'd like a second opinion on these. I had to make a collage pic since they are Too large to upload and I'm not tech-y (or tech-ie) lol

the saddle on the right is ours. the left and middle are the ones I am trying to decide on. I'm leaning towards the left one. Ours doesn't have a serial so that's why I can find out exactly what bars it it. 

https://photos.app.goo.gl/4fyF1yMn7LtyrrnS8