|
|
Veteran
Posts: 144
 
| I've heard from several people that they've really stepped up their game lately. True? If you own one of the newer ones, would you purchase again? | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 1631
 
Location: Somewhere around here | I'll be the odd man out. I really like mine. I've bought 3 in the past 6 months, first two were used then bought the one I really like this past month. My goal is eventually buying a Bob Marshall but something always seems to come up when I do have enough money to buy a used one that doesn't need repairs. First one was good but too big, then I bought a 15 which I really liked but I traded it for a nice Cactus barrel saddle, ended up hating the saddle. So I sold it and bought a Hilason from their site and I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing I wish I could change would be a higher perched front for higher withered horses. No it's not the prettiest one out there, it's much like a Basic Barrel From Original Bob Marshall site, but it's helped my horse a lot and I'm super comfortable in it. The leather is actually pretty nice and I'm not going to complain about it. I have owned a Tammy Fischer in the past and honestly I don't feel any difference between the leather quality of the Tammy and a Hilason. I didn't like the Tammy because it held me in too much and I'm able to move around more in the Hilason. It doesn't feel like it's going to fall apart, I can feel my horse move better, and my horse works better too. Here's a picture
http://i65.tinypic.com/3144d3n.jpg
.
http://i65.tinypic.com/1zow5n5.jpg
Edited by cecollins0811 2018-03-19 8:07 AM
| |
| | |
 Off the Wall Wacky
Posts: 2981
Location: Louisiana | cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 8:06 AM
I'll be the odd man out. I really like mine. I've bought 3 in the past 6 months, first two were used then bought the one I really like this past month. My goal is eventually buying a Bob Marshall but something always seems to come up when I do have enough money to buy a used one that doesn't need repairs. First one was good but too big, then I bought a 15 which I really liked but I traded it for a nice Cactus barrel saddle, ended up hating the saddle. So I sold it and bought a Hilason from their site and I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing I wish I could change would be a higher perched front for higher withered horses. No it's not the prettiest one out there, it's much like a Basic Barrel From Original Bob Marshall site, but it's helped my horse a lot and I'm super comfortable in it. The leather is actually pretty nice and I'm not going to complain about it. I have owned a Tammy Fischer in the past and honestly I don't feel any difference between the leather quality of the Tammy and a Hilason. I didn't like the Tammy because it held me in too much and I'm able to move around more in the Hilason. It doesn't feel like it's going to fall apart, I can feel my horse move better, and my horse works better too. Here's a picture
http://i65.tinypic.com/3144d3n.jpg
.
http://i65.tinypic.com/1zow5n5.jpg
How do the stirrups hang compared to your Tammy you had?
I just sold my Tammy and bought a cheap older Circle Y Bob, but the stirrups are WAY different and my feet want to get behind me, which I've never had that issue before.
I was thinking about selling it and buying a Hilason. I have one horse that needs a treeless, but he's semi-retired and doesn't get ridden much. So I don't want to spend much, but do want him comfortable when I do get to ride him. Which was why I bought the old beat up Circle Y, but the "feel" is just very very different to me. | |
| | |
Expert
Posts: 1631
Location: Somewhere around here | dashnlotti - 2018-03-19 9:26 AM
cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 8:06 AM
I'll be the odd man out. I really like mine. I've bought 3 in the past 6 months, first two were used then bought the one I really like this past month. My goal is eventually buying a Bob Marshall but something always seems to come up when I do have enough money to buy a used one that doesn't need repairs. First one was good but too big, then I bought a 15 which I really liked but I traded it for a nice Cactus barrel saddle, ended up hating the saddle. So I sold it and bought a Hilason from their site and I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing I wish I could change would be a higher perched front for higher withered horses. No it's not the prettiest one out there, it's much like a Basic Barrel From Original Bob Marshall site, but it's helped my horse a lot and I'm super comfortable in it. The leather is actually pretty nice and I'm not going to complain about it. I have owned a Tammy Fischer in the past and honestly I don't feel any difference between the leather quality of the Tammy and a Hilason. I didn't like the Tammy because it held me in too much and I'm able to move around more in the Hilason. It doesn't feel like it's going to fall apart, I can feel my horse move better, and my horse works better too. Here's a picture
http://i65.tinypic.com/3144d3n.jpg
.
http://i65.tinypic.com/1zow5n5.jpg
How do the stirrups hang compared to your Tammy you had?
I just sold my Tammy and bought a cheap older Circle Y Bob, but the stirrups are WAY different and my feet want to get behind me, which I've never had that issue before.
I was thinking about selling it and buying a Hilason. I have one horse that needs a treeless, but he's semi-retired and doesn't get ridden much. So I don't want to spend much, but do want him comfortable when I do get to ride him. Which was why I bought the old beat up Circle Y, but the "feel" is just very very different to me.
Could you explain how the "feel" is different from the Tammy to the Bob? I'm just curious. I honestly like the original stirrups it came with, my feet didn't get ahead of me nor behind me, but my legs are so short that the highest hole was just a smidge too long, so I ordered custom straps from "Harness The Wind" Facebook page. I've ordered from her two times and she's very easy and nice to work with. I don't like forward hanging stirrups so these are perfect for me. I have to mention that I prefer the Hilason treeless saddles that are their main style, like the ones that look like Tammy's/Bob's/Jackie's instead of regular looking ones. I've never had a regular looking one, but I think I'll just stick with what I know and like. | |
| | |
Off the Wall Wacky
Posts: 2981
Location: Louisiana | cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 10:57 AM
dashnlotti - 2018-03-19 9:26 AM
cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 8:06 AM
I'll be the odd man out. I really like mine. I've bought 3 in the past 6 months, first two were used then bought the one I really like this past month. My goal is eventually buying a Bob Marshall but something always seems to come up when I do have enough money to buy a used one that doesn't need repairs. First one was good but too big, then I bought a 15 which I really liked but I traded it for a nice Cactus barrel saddle, ended up hating the saddle. So I sold it and bought a Hilason from their site and I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing I wish I could change would be a higher perched front for higher withered horses. No it's not the prettiest one out there, it's much like a Basic Barrel From Original Bob Marshall site, but it's helped my horse a lot and I'm super comfortable in it. The leather is actually pretty nice and I'm not going to complain about it. I have owned a Tammy Fischer in the past and honestly I don't feel any difference between the leather quality of the Tammy and a Hilason. I didn't like the Tammy because it held me in too much and I'm able to move around more in the Hilason. It doesn't feel like it's going to fall apart, I can feel my horse move better, and my horse works better too. Here's a picture
http://i65.tinypic.com/3144d3n.jpg
.
http://i65.tinypic.com/1zow5n5.jpg
How do the stirrups hang compared to your Tammy you had?
I just sold my Tammy and bought a cheap older Circle Y Bob, but the stirrups are WAY different and my feet want to get behind me, which I've never had that issue before.
I was thinking about selling it and buying a Hilason. I have one horse that needs a treeless, but he's semi-retired and doesn't get ridden much. So I don't want to spend much, but do want him comfortable when I do get to ride him. Which was why I bought the old beat up Circle Y, but the "feel" is just very very different to me.
Could you explain how the "feel" is different from the Tammy to the Bob? I'm just curious. I honestly like the original stirrups it came with, my feet didn't get ahead of me nor behind me, but my legs are so short that the highest hole was just a smidge too long, so I ordered custom straps from "Harness The Wind" Facebook page. I've ordered from her two times and she's very easy and nice to work with. I don't like forward hanging stirrups so these are perfect for me. I have to mention that I prefer the Hilason treeless saddles that are their main style, like the ones that look like Tammy's/Bob's/Jackie's instead of regular looking ones. I've never had a regular looking one, but I think I'll just stick with what I know and like.
My Tammy seems to keep my feet a bit in front of me...which I've gotten used to since I have strictly ridden in it for a few years. I can't remember how my old original Bob felt.
This Circle Y Bob, the stirrups hang on a rounded dee and when I "get up" in the saddle, my feet go right out behind me. And it could simply be the fact that I've gotten so used to the other and just need to adjust to this one. I also need to do like you did and buy new, shorter straps bc I'm on the top hole and they need to come up more - which could be making the issue worse! | |
| | |
Expert
Posts: 1631
Location: Somewhere around here | dashnlotti - 2018-03-19 10:17 AM
cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 10:57 AM
dashnlotti - 2018-03-19 9:26 AM
cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 8:06 AM
I'll be the odd man out. I really like mine. I've bought 3 in the past 6 months, first two were used then bought the one I really like this past month. My goal is eventually buying a Bob Marshall but something always seems to come up when I do have enough money to buy a used one that doesn't need repairs. First one was good but too big, then I bought a 15 which I really liked but I traded it for a nice Cactus barrel saddle, ended up hating the saddle. So I sold it and bought a Hilason from their site and I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing I wish I could change would be a higher perched front for higher withered horses. No it's not the prettiest one out there, it's much like a Basic Barrel From Original Bob Marshall site, but it's helped my horse a lot and I'm super comfortable in it. The leather is actually pretty nice and I'm not going to complain about it. I have owned a Tammy Fischer in the past and honestly I don't feel any difference between the leather quality of the Tammy and a Hilason. I didn't like the Tammy because it held me in too much and I'm able to move around more in the Hilason. It doesn't feel like it's going to fall apart, I can feel my horse move better, and my horse works better too. Here's a picture
http://i65.tinypic.com/3144d3n.jpg
.
http://i65.tinypic.com/1zow5n5.jpg
How do the stirrups hang compared to your Tammy you had?
I just sold my Tammy and bought a cheap older Circle Y Bob, but the stirrups are WAY different and my feet want to get behind me, which I've never had that issue before.
I was thinking about selling it and buying a Hilason. I have one horse that needs a treeless, but he's semi-retired and doesn't get ridden much. So I don't want to spend much, but do want him comfortable when I do get to ride him. Which was why I bought the old beat up Circle Y, but the "feel" is just very very different to me.
Could you explain how the "feel" is different from the Tammy to the Bob? I'm just curious. I honestly like the original stirrups it came with, my feet didn't get ahead of me nor behind me, but my legs are so short that the highest hole was just a smidge too long, so I ordered custom straps from "Harness The Wind" Facebook page. I've ordered from her two times and she's very easy and nice to work with. I don't like forward hanging stirrups so these are perfect for me. I have to mention that I prefer the Hilason treeless saddles that are their main style, like the ones that look like Tammy's/Bob's/Jackie's instead of regular looking ones. I've never had a regular looking one, but I think I'll just stick with what I know and like.
My Tammy seems to keep my feet a bit in front of me...which I've gotten used to since I have strictly ridden in it for a few years. I can't remember how my old original Bob felt.
This Circle Y Bob, the stirrups hang on a rounded dee and when I "get up" in the saddle, my feet go right out behind me. And it could simply be the fact that I've gotten so used to the other and just need to adjust to this one. I also need to do like you did and buy new, shorter straps bc I'm on the top hole and they need to come up more - which could be making the issue worse!
That's exactly how my Hilason is, it's on a rounded D as well. My feet tend to go a little back as well when I ride in the stirrup straps too long. So it definitely could just be you needing shorter ones. | |
| | |
Off the Wall Wacky
Posts: 2981
Location: Louisiana | cecollins0811 - 2018-03-20 7:22 AM
dashnlotti - 2018-03-19 10:17 AM
cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 10:57 AM
dashnlotti - 2018-03-19 9:26 AM
cecollins0811 - 2018-03-19 8:06 AM
I'll be the odd man out. I really like mine. I've bought 3 in the past 6 months, first two were used then bought the one I really like this past month. My goal is eventually buying a Bob Marshall but something always seems to come up when I do have enough money to buy a used one that doesn't need repairs. First one was good but too big, then I bought a 15 which I really liked but I traded it for a nice Cactus barrel saddle, ended up hating the saddle. So I sold it and bought a Hilason from their site and I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing I wish I could change would be a higher perched front for higher withered horses. No it's not the prettiest one out there, it's much like a Basic Barrel From Original Bob Marshall site, but it's helped my horse a lot and I'm super comfortable in it. The leather is actually pretty nice and I'm not going to complain about it. I have owned a Tammy Fischer in the past and honestly I don't feel any difference between the leather quality of the Tammy and a Hilason. I didn't like the Tammy because it held me in too much and I'm able to move around more in the Hilason. It doesn't feel like it's going to fall apart, I can feel my horse move better, and my horse works better too. Here's a picture
http://i65.tinypic.com/3144d3n.jpg
.
http://i65.tinypic.com/1zow5n5.jpg
How do the stirrups hang compared to your Tammy you had?
I just sold my Tammy and bought a cheap older Circle Y Bob, but the stirrups are WAY different and my feet want to get behind me, which I've never had that issue before.
I was thinking about selling it and buying a Hilason. I have one horse that needs a treeless, but he's semi-retired and doesn't get ridden much. So I don't want to spend much, but do want him comfortable when I do get to ride him. Which was why I bought the old beat up Circle Y, but the "feel" is just very very different to me.
Could you explain how the "feel" is different from the Tammy to the Bob? I'm just curious. I honestly like the original stirrups it came with, my feet didn't get ahead of me nor behind me, but my legs are so short that the highest hole was just a smidge too long, so I ordered custom straps from "Harness The Wind" Facebook page. I've ordered from her two times and she's very easy and nice to work with. I don't like forward hanging stirrups so these are perfect for me. I have to mention that I prefer the Hilason treeless saddles that are their main style, like the ones that look like Tammy's/Bob's/Jackie's instead of regular looking ones. I've never had a regular looking one, but I think I'll just stick with what I know and like.
My Tammy seems to keep my feet a bit in front of me...which I've gotten used to since I have strictly ridden in it for a few years. I can't remember how my old original Bob felt.
This Circle Y Bob, the stirrups hang on a rounded dee and when I "get up" in the saddle, my feet go right out behind me. And it could simply be the fact that I've gotten so used to the other and just need to adjust to this one. I also need to do like you did and buy new, shorter straps bc I'm on the top hole and they need to come up more - which could be making the issue worse!
That's exactly how my Hilason is, it's on a rounded D as well. My feet tend to go a little back as well when I ride in the stirrup straps too long. So it definitely could just be you needing shorter ones.
You were right. They actually still had one hole left (hard to see with those buckles lol), took them up and it made a huge difference!!
| |
| | |
Veteran
Posts: 144
| I have a horse with pronounced withers. Guessing they won't work for her? :( | |
| | |
 Expert
Posts: 3815
Location: The best kept secret in TX | BayRoan - 2018-03-21 7:25 AM I have a horse with pronounced withers. Guessing they won't work for her? :(
You should be fine as long as you have a cut back pad. I know Bob Marshall offers a High wither relief treeless. Hilason may as well if you are wanting to go this route. In the past the leather and craftsmanship have been less than decent. I can't speak for the new ones... | |
| | |
Expert
Posts: 1631
Location: Somewhere around here | IRunOnFaith - 2018-03-21 7:29 AM
BayRoan - 2018-03-21 7:25 AM I have a horse with pronounced withers. Guessing they won't work for her? :(
You should be fine as long as you have a cut back pad. I know Bob Marshall offers a High wither relief treeless. Hilason may as well if you are wanting to go this route. In the past the leather and craftsmanship have been less than decent. I can't speak for the new ones...
Agreed. My horse had a broad back but higher withers, so he's been doing pretty good with a regular 5 star cut saddle pad. I'm contemplating on buying a saddle pad with a wither cutout, but I'm just guessing it depends on your horse. | |
| |
| |
Folks on-line