Jeff Smith vs Robbie Phillips Saddles. How do they compare... pros and cons of each? Thanks 

I can only speak for Jeff Smith....the customer service is unmatched. I have ordered 3 saddles from him the last one had a small defect and the buckstitch was not done on the cantle. They sent me a label for me to ship back fixed it reoiled it and gave me a pair of nettles. It was back at my door in a week. 

I have never had a Jeff Smith, but I love my Robbies!  

Its all I ride in, and Robbie is super easy to deal with, and get the right fit for your horse. I can stay sat down and they fit the horses great 

How do they compare on price?

Not sure on Jeff Smith but the last Robbie I ordered was about 4 years ago, it was 3500 

Love my robbie. Had my mare fitted by him. He was great to work with. I got mine with the cut out swels. Helps keep me in better. 

Both are solid brands, but they feel a bit different depending on what you like. Jeff Smith saddles are often praised for their balance and fit, especially for riders who want a more secure seat. Robbie Phillips saddles tend to feel lighter and more flexible, which some horses seem to move better in. It really comes down to fit for your horse and personal preference—if you can, try both before deciding.

Both are quality custom makers, really comes down to your horse's back shape and your riding style. Jeff Smith runs a bit narrower in the tree for flat-backed horses while Robbie tends to work better on more mutton-withered QH types. Agree with everyone on customer service — both builders are hands-on. Main things I'd consider: seat size (don't size down thinking you'll break it in), horn height for your reach, and whether you want a deeper pocket seat or flatter. If you're between them, ask both builders to measure your horse's back with a wire form. Most custom makers will do it free if you mail it in.

Honestly, if you can, sit in both before spending the money. Saddle fit for you and the horse beats brand names every time. One rider’s dream saddle is another rider’s back pain lol.

I have a Jeff Smith custom and love it.  By far the most comfortable and functionable saddle I've ever had.  I can't speak for Robbie's but I usually hear nothing but good about them.