Jeff Smith vs Robbie Phillips Saddles. How do they compare... pros and cons of each? Thanks 

I can only speak for Jeff Smith....the customer service is unmatched. I have ordered 3 saddles from him the last one had a small defect and the buckstitch was not done on the cantle. They sent me a label for me to ship back fixed it reoiled it and gave me a pair of nettles. It was back at my door in a week. 

I have never had a Jeff Smith, but I love my Robbies!  

Its all I ride in, and Robbie is super easy to deal with, and get the right fit for your horse. I can stay sat down and they fit the horses great 

How do they compare on price?

Not sure on Jeff Smith but the last Robbie I ordered was about 4 years ago, it was 3500 

Love my robbie. Had my mare fitted by him. He was great to work with. I got mine with the cut out swels. Helps keep me in better.