|
|
 Expert
Posts: 1258
  
Location: MN | I recently bought a horse from OK completely sound with shoes on, well I live in MN and take shoes off in the winter up here. I have nowhere to ride indoor's and I'm in the process of finding a decent farrier anyway so I board him at my friend's house an hour away so I can continue to ride daily but have no farrier that I know that will go up that far. Therefore I had a farrier that I didn't know last Friday pull my horses shoes and trim him, ok fine. Sunday I go to ride and he is sore, gave him bute and let him rest, same thing with Monday , Tuesday, wed, etc, so much so that he didn't even want to go outside on frozen ground to his outdoor paddock. At this point, I'm upset, farrier can't get there till yesterday (Sat.) I had an open house so hubby is going to hold my horse while farrier looks at him, I call hubby and asked how it is going and he said well, "the vet is on the way, your horse's feet are hot, all 4, they are going to give him IV DMSO" Make a long story short that is what they did, so happens farrier and vet are husband and wife, and he is not taking the blame for cutting him too short, I am LIVID!!! There is nothing else that would have caused this horse to go lame, they put shoes and pads back on and he is walking better, but the previous owner who had him for 13 years said he had nothing wrong, and he passed and extensive vet check, and this farrier is saying he had thin soles as of yesterday, when he said last Friday he didn't think they were at at!!!! Has anyone else had their horse's feet come up hot after trimming too short? |
|
| |
|
  JMHO
Posts: 1869
Location: Oklahoma | Here is my opinion. We've bred the feet right out from under a lot of these horses. Now, you go to Walmart, take your shoes off and run around bare foot on the cold hard ground 10 hours or more and see how your feet fair. I'd be in tears after the first few hours. Thin soles or not THE GROUND IS FROZEN and the horse is use to HIS SHOES! Without xrays, how is the Farrier to know your horse has thin soles? Look in the mirror if you need to place blame somewhere. Lesson learned. |
|
| |
|
Expert
Posts: 1258
Location: MN | Dreamin of 3cans - 2014-12-07 7:19 AM
Here is my opinion. We've bred the feet right out from under a lot of these horses. Now, you go to Walmart, take your shoes off and run around bare foot on the cold hard ground 10 hours or more and see how your feet fair. I'd be in tears after the first few hours. Thin soles or not THE GROUND IS FROZEN and the horse is use to HIS SHOES! Without xrays, how is the Farrier to know your horse has thin soles? Look in the mirror if you need to place blame somewhere. Lesson learned.Â
First of all, What does Walmart have to do with anything? second, this horse is on soft ground in a heated barn most of the time and is still sore, and in an arena where it is very soft, 3rd, I don't think it is normal for ANY horse to get his shoes off, trimmed, then his feet come up warm!! So your comment about him being on hard ground for 10 hours or more is complete naivety. This horse has had nothing but care since he's been here miss "basher", so thanks for your reply, but before your next reply don't assume anything especially someone going to "Walmart" to take there shoes off before you give your next bit of input, and by the way, I did look in the mirror, and liked what I saw, THANKS THO!! |
|
| |
|
 I Am Always Right
Posts: 4264
Location: stray dump capital of the world | snoopy - 2014-12-07 7:37 AM Dreamin of 3cans - 2014-12-07 7:19 AM Here is my opinion. We've bred the feet right out from under a lot of these horses. Now, you go to Walmart, take your shoes off and run around bare foot on the cold hard ground 10 hours or more and see how your feet fair. I'd be in tears after the first few hours. Thin soles or not THE GROUND IS FROZEN and the horse is use to HIS SHOES! Without xrays, how is the Farrier to know your horse has thin soles? Look in the mirror if you need to place blame somewhere. Lesson learned. First of all, What does Walmart have to do with anything? second, this horse is on soft ground in a heated barn most of the time and is still sore, and in an arena where it is very soft, 3rd, I don't think it is normal for ANY horse to get his shoes off, trimmed, then his feet come up warm!! So your comment about him being on hard ground for 10 hours or more is complete naivety. This horse has had nothing but care since he's been here miss "basher", so thanks for your reply, but before your next reply don't assume anything especially someone going to "Walmart" to take there shoes off before you give your next bit of input, and by the way, I did look in the mirror, and liked what I saw, THANKS THO!!
I think what she meant in her reply was the horse was used to being shod. His shoes were pulled and not accustom to frozen ground; therefore, they became sore. She equated it with us suddenly going barefoot. Naturally, we'd be sore.
I would probably, at this point, take the horse to a different vet for a 2nd opinion.
Wishing you the best of luck. |
|
| |
|
| 1. Trimmed too short
2. Horse rarely barefoot so never developed hard feet
3. Abscesses?
4. Big change of country and weather and horse trying to acclimate is affecting his feet also.
Just some ideas.
|
|
| |
|
 Angel in a Sorrel Coat
Posts: 16030
Location: In a happy place | I know of something like this happening before. One thing if I take shoes off I never let the farrier trim shape or whatever. I just leave the feet and most of the time I don't have any problems. |
|
| |
|
Expert
Posts: 1543
Location: MI | Maybe ask his old owners if he was ever barefoot before? Because that, as well as the change in the ground hardness, may mean that he would need a good month or 2, if not more, to adjust to not having shoes on. It sounds like hoof problems typically don't turn around overnight.
My farrier has said Iodine on their soles can help harden them, if that is the desired goal.
Hope you get it all sorted out. It sounds like you take very good care of him. |
|
| |
|
 Northern Chocolate Queen
Posts: 16576
Location: ND | There's lots of little things here that could be the start of your problem. First I never pull shoes & trim at the same time. I pull the shoes & allow them to go as is for a couple weeks while they adjust to not having the protection of the shoe. Then after I know they're moving good I'll trim them. When I trim I do not EVER touch the live sole, I'll take out the loose flakey material but that is it. A larger percentage of farriers believe in cutting a bunch of sole out which thins the sole & makes them very sensitive. And going from shod to freshly trimmed & barefoot on hard frozen ground is hard for them. Walking on frozen turds & any uneven clumpy ground will easily leave a tender/soft foot very bruised. |
|
| |
|
 Damn Yankee
Posts: 12390
Location: Somewhere between raising hell and Amazing Grace | I've seen it happen. Too many times. Remember as kids we used to run around everywhere barefoot?
Do you think you could do it now without getting sore feet? If your guy has been shod for a long time, then even if it was done perfect, he could still come up sore right after pulling his shoes until he gets used to running around barefoot again. |
|
| |
|
The Advice Guru
Posts: 6419
| I wouldn't be blaming the farrier for a few reasons
If the horse had shoes on for a lengthy time even on soft ground without shoes they can become sore.
When the shoes got pulled you rode the horse within a few days, you never gave the horse time to adjust to no shoes and even this alone can cause enough stress for a sensitive horse to develop laminitis and founder.
Even if the ground is soft all it takes is one hard spot, one rock, etc can cause bruising which can cause heat and worst case can cause founder.
If this was my horse I would be anticipating abscesses occuring. I wouldn't have put pads on as now you are not able to poultice the feet. I would have packed the feet with magic cushion as it has anti inflammatory properties and poulticing properties. I would also discuss with a vet about banamine for a few days to keep inflammation out of the feet. |
|
| |
|
Northern Chocolate Queen
Posts: 16576
Location: ND | Another thing to consider is his diet. Are you feeding the same feed and type of hay/alfalfa the previous owner did? If what you are feeding is quite a bit different than what they previous owner did it could also be part of what is going on. |
|
| |
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 349
| SaraJean - 2014-12-07 7:37 AM
There's lots of little things here that could be the start of your problem. First I never pull shoes & trim at the same time. I pull the shoes & allow them to go as is for a couple weeks while they adjust to not having the protection of the shoe. Then after I know they're moving good I'll trim them. When I trim I do not EVER touch the live sole, I'll take out the loose flakey material but that is it. A larger percentage of farriers believe in cutting a bunch of sole out which thins the sole & makes them very sensitive. And going from shod to freshly trimmed & barefoot on hard frozen ground is hard for them. Walking on frozen turds & any uneven clumpy ground will easily leave a tender/soft foot very bruised.
 This. The shod to barefoot transition in itself can be hard to adjust to for a horse then add the frozen aspects in. If hoof angles are right all I ever do on my horses is trim and round the wall. It is amazing what even a hoof that has been in shoes can do to protect itself and build callus. |
|
| |
|
 Money Eating Baggage Owner
Posts: 9586
Location: Phoenix | Sounds pretty normal. When pulling shoes for the first time in a while you don't want to trim the foot. That's one of the reasons he's sore. The second reason is the ground is frozen! I also pull shoes in the winter and my horse is always a little ouchy. I would say the issue here is he was trimmed after pulling the shoes. Hope he feels better. |
|
| |
|
 Expert
Posts: 4121
Location: SE Louisiana | Trimming the hoof wall back somewhat if it is long is not out of the question.. pairing out the sole IS... If you leave long or flared wall in a case like this you are just asking to start cracks running up the walls.. |
|
| |
|
 Sock eating dog owner
Posts: 4557
Location: Where the pavement ends and the West begins Utah | Very normal ..but if the feet are hot the horse may be trying to founder or an abcess is in process. Get a bottle of iodine and place it on the bottom of the feet. 2 don't use that pair again. Your horse will take a few weeks to come back get some boots in the mean time. |
|
| |
|
 Elite Veteran
Posts: 1182
Location: Do I hear Banjos? | Cheryl has the right answer here:
"I wouldn't have put pads on as now you are not able to poultice the feet. I would have packed the feet with magic cushion as it has anti inflammatory properties and poulticing properties. I would also discuss with a vet about banamine for a few days to keep inflammation out of the feet."
This is often the outcome of pulling shoes when a horse has been shod a long time and not giving time for the transition. Hard winter ground and riding just exacerbates the problem. Some horses do tend to have tender feet or thinner soles and when used to being shod it can be a little tougher to transition. Packing with Magic Cushion (stupid name for a great product...makes it sound like snake oil but this stuff works!)...and using soft rides to transition often is the ticket.
I sure wouldn't have put shoes and pads back on...but that's just me.
I have a tender footed BIG appy that is mostly retired and we used the magic cushion and soft rides to transition him to barefoot on our somewhat rocky Arkansas pastures. He is comfy now but it took time. And we don't ride him barefoot. He can't handle that comfortably even now. So boots or shoes are needed.
|
|
| |
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 512
| I had purchased a horse that had been turned out for a year without shoes. His feet were longer and not the best kept. My farrier came out and trimmed him up and my horse responded the same way. He could barely move that evening and his feet were hot. With pain management and rest he was better within a week. But we switched farriers and I haven't had a problem with him since. The previous owners never had this problem either. |
|
| |
|
 Lady Di
Posts: 21556
Location: Oklahoma | cheryl makofka - 2014-12-07 10:30 AM
I wouldn't be blaming the farrier for a few reasons
If the horse had shoes on for a lengthy time even on soft ground without shoes they can become sore.
When the shoes got pulled you rode the horse within a few days, you never gave the horse time to adjust to no shoes and even this alone can cause enough stress for a sensitive horse to develop laminitis and founder.
Even if the ground is soft all it takes is one hard spot, one rock, etc can cause bruising which can cause heat and worst case can cause founder.
If this was my horse I would be anticipating abscesses occuring. I wouldn't have put pads on as now you are not able to poultice the feet. I would have packed the feet with magic cushion as it has anti inflammatory properties and poulticing properties. I would also discuss with a vet about banamine for a few days to keep inflammation out of the feet.
I would be blaming the farrier, pure and simple. This was my horse she bought and he's never taken a lame step his whole life, barefoot or not and has had a myriad of shoers. He does NOT have thin soles unless this idiot pared so much away that he does now. She's keeping him in a stall and riding in an indoor, not on frozen ground. You should see the shoes he put on this poor horse. They're at least two sizes too small and has his toe run out to the front. Looks like to me he could have looked at the shoes he pulled off and known what size to put back on him, and any decent farrier I know, knows not to trim them much when they pull shoes off. They usually just rasp the edges a little. This was incompetence, pure and simple, and she has every right to be furious at the farrier. When a horse gets so bad that he is foundering from the pain, that is definitely his fault. He should have known better. He cut him so short he barely has any foot left.
Edited by dianeguinn 2014-12-08 1:56 PM
|
|
| |
|
The Advice Guru
Posts: 6419
| dianeguinn - 2014-12-08 1:52 PM
cheryl makofka - 2014-12-07 10:30 AM
I wouldn't be blaming the farrier for a few reasons
If the horse had shoes on for a lengthy time even on soft ground without shoes they can become sore.
When the shoes got pulled you rode the horse within a few days, you never gave the horse time to adjust to no shoes and even this alone can cause enough stress for a sensitive horse to develop laminitis and founder.
Even if the ground is soft all it takes is one hard spot, one rock, etc can cause bruising which can cause heat and worst case can cause founder.
If this was my horse I would be anticipating abscesses occuring. I wouldn't have put pads on as now you are not able to poultice the feet. I would have packed the feet with magic cushion as it has anti inflammatory properties and poulticing properties. I would also discuss with a vet about banamine for a few days to keep inflammation out of the feet.
I would be blaming the farrier, pure and simple. This was my horse she bought and he's never taken a lame step his whole life, barefoot or not and has had a myriad of shoers. He does NOT have thin soles unless this idiot pared so much away that he does now. She's keeping him in a stall and riding in an indoor, not on frozen ground. You should see the shoes he put on this poor horse. They're at least two sizes too small and has his toe run out to the front. Looks like to me he could have looked at the shoes he pulled off and known what size to put back on him, and any decent farrier I know, knows not to trim them much when they pull shoes off. They usually just rasp the edges a little. This was incompetence, pure and simple, and she has every right to be furious at the farrier. When a horse gets so bad that he is foundering from the pain, that is definitely his fault. He should have known better. He cut him so short he barely has any foot left.
Diane you may know a little more then us
But she said she is turning him out in a paddock with frozen ground. The frozen ground can cause bruising especially on a horse who just got the shoes pulled. If the ground is freezing I am assuming the manure is freezing which is perfect for causing bruises when a horse steps on them.
I don't blame the horse not the farrier, it sounds like lack of education
She also said the horse was sound with shoes on, to me this generally means horse is not sound barefoot. It is all wording but with the information she gave you cannot blame the farrier.
With what you are saying yes I would be mad at the farrier too but how or where is the horse trimmed too short if his toe is too long? Did the farrier butcher the heels?
The horse was lame prior to the shoes being reapplied so it wasn't the shoe job that caused the lamness, but the op is going to have to address too small of shoes as this will cause more foot problems contracted heels and later on navicular problems. |
|
| |
|
Lady Di
Posts: 21556
Location: Oklahoma | cheryl makofka - 2014-12-08 2:20 PM
dianeguinn - 2014-12-08 1:52 PM
cheryl makofka - 2014-12-07 10:30 AM
I wouldn't be blaming the farrier for a few reasons
If the horse had shoes on for a lengthy time even on soft ground without shoes they can become sore.
When the shoes got pulled you rode the horse within a few days, you never gave the horse time to adjust to no shoes and even this alone can cause enough stress for a sensitive horse to develop laminitis and founder.
Even if the ground is soft all it takes is one hard spot, one rock, etc can cause bruising which can cause heat and worst case can cause founder.
If this was my horse I would be anticipating abscesses occuring. I wouldn't have put pads on as now you are not able to poultice the feet. I would have packed the feet with magic cushion as it has anti inflammatory properties and poulticing properties. I would also discuss with a vet about banamine for a few days to keep inflammation out of the feet.
I would be blaming the farrier, pure and simple. This was my horse she bought and he's never taken a lame step his whole life, barefoot or not and has had a myriad of shoers. He does NOT have thin soles unless this idiot pared so much away that he does now. She's keeping him in a stall and riding in an indoor, not on frozen ground. You should see the shoes he put on this poor horse. They're at least two sizes too small and has his toe run out to the front. Looks like to me he could have looked at the shoes he pulled off and known what size to put back on him, and any decent farrier I know, knows not to trim them much when they pull shoes off. They usually just rasp the edges a little. This was incompetence, pure and simple, and she has every right to be furious at the farrier. When a horse gets so bad that he is foundering from the pain, that is definitely his fault. He should have known better. He cut him so short he barely has any foot left.
Diane you may know a little more then us
But she said she is turning him out in a paddock with frozen ground. The frozen ground can cause bruising especially on a horse who just got the shoes pulled. If the ground is freezing I am assuming the manure is freezing which is perfect for causing bruises when a horse steps on them.
I don't blame the horse not the farrier, it sounds like lack of education
She also said the horse was sound with shoes on, to me this generally means horse is not sound barefoot. It is all wording but with the information she gave you cannot blame the farrier.
With what you are saying yes I would be mad at the farrier too but how or where is the horse trimmed too short if his toe is too long? Did the farrier butcher the heels?
The horse was lame prior to the shoes being reapplied so it wasn't the shoe job that caused the lamness, but the op is going to have to address too small of shoes as this will cause more foot problems contracted heels and later on navicular problems.
That's exactly what I told her. She is looking for a new farrier as we speak and is going to try to get that shoe job corrected. She'd never used this guy and no one told her that he wasn't any good until AFTER he screwed up her horse. You'd never buy a horse from me, as I keep all of mine shod, as most people want their performance horses shod when they buy them. It has nothing to do with having foot problems. Almost no one goes barefoot around here, but we have good farriers that know not to cut off the heel and stick shoes two sizes too small on them, plus pare out the sole an inch or two, especially if they're going to go barefoot. smh |
|
| |
Folks on-line