Log in to my account Barrel Horse World
Come on in Folks on-line

Today is

You are logged in as a guest. Logon or register an account to access more features.


Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study

Jump to page :
Last activity 2015-07-25 9:14 PM
36 replies, 7956 views

View previous thread :: View next thread
   General Discussion -> Barrel Talk
Refresh
 
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-20 9:24 AM
Subject: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
 https://nouvelleresearch.com/index.php/articles/393-probiotics-are-they-necessary
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
TurnLane
Reg. May 2007
Posted 2015-07-20 12:21 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study



Pork Fat is my Favorite


Posts: 3791
20001000500100100252525
Location: The Oklahoma plains.
Very interesting. So what do you think?  
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-20 1:06 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
Welllll....through the years I have fed probiotics and prebiotics and never saw a huge difference.  The prebiotics seemed to make my horses gassy.  The probiotics didn't make much difference at all.  I think that if we can eliminate the inflammation in the hind gut and maintain a healthy PH that we don't have the need for either and our horses are better for it.  I think we, as humans, and these horses being like our children, sometimes have a tendency to over-do it with trying to do the best we can for them and that in turn we often end up being counter productive through over feeding, over supplementing, and over medicating....this includes pro and prebiotics IMO. 
 

Edited by Herbie 2015-07-20 1:08 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
lonely va barrelxr
Reg. Apr 2005
Posted 2015-07-20 1:28 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study



Reaching for the stars....


Posts: 12708
500050002000500100100
Herbie - 2015-07-20 1:06 PM Welllll....through the years I have fed probiotics and prebiotics and never saw a huge difference.  The prebiotics seemed to make my horses gassy.  The probiotics didn't make much difference at all.  I think that if we can eliminate the inflammation in the hind gut and maintain a healthy PH that we don't have the need for either and our horses are better for it.  I think we, as humans, and these horses being like our children, sometimes have a tendency to over-do it with trying to do the best we can for them and that in turn we often end up being counter productive through over feeding, over supplementing, and over medicating....this includes pro and prebiotics IMO. 

 




I like the way you think . .  
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
TurnLane
Reg. May 2007
Posted 2015-07-20 2:43 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study



Pork Fat is my Favorite


Posts: 3791
20001000500100100252525
Location: The Oklahoma plains.
How do you think one would go about eliminating the inflamation in the hind gut? I tend to follow yout thinking as well but I am certainly no expert. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Sandok
Reg. Jan 2011
Posted 2015-07-20 2:51 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Expert


Posts: 1207
1000100100
I am by far not an expert on anything. Just trying to find something a little more simplified. As far as I know, none of my horses have any issues with gastro, ulcers, etc. I am more interested in inflamanation of the whole body and it seems like that is what this is talking about.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-20 3:46 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
I am certainly no expert either, TurnLane, but in trying to find something to help my horse with his respiratory conditions, I began giving him french's mustard, and through that I did notice a very slight improvement in him after MONTHS and thousands of dollars spent on vets and drugs and supplements, etc.  I googled to find out what was in the French's and found turmeric, vinegar and water to be the only ingredients, so I then googled turmeric (curcurmin) and was blown away at all of the things I found in how it benefits people who consume it....things from treating IBS, to cancer, to arthritis, pain management, allergies, COPD, etc.....and not only is it just articles, but studies that document the progress of people taking curcurmin supplements.  In talking to one of my good friends about this, she said her mother and aunt take it for their RLS and they cured a very allergic/itchy dog with dermatitis in feeding it to the dog as well. 

I continued my google search but specified for horses and ran across the Cur-Ost company (www.nouvelleresearch.com) and began consulting with Dr. Schell on the issues with my horse, speaking primarily on the respiratory issues.  After about  weeks of him consulting with me (aka, me driving him crazy, i'm sure), I finally ordered the product.  Through the use of this product, I know that I know longer have a hind gut issue.  Even before this horse got sick, he has always been very irritable and very touchy where a back cinch would go.  He's always been very flinchy even when you brush him.  I've been through countless rounds of omeprazole, ranitidine, etc and while he would improve a little, these symptoms would never go away.  The change in this horse's attitude and overall well being is truly remarkable.  He has always been a little on the hateful side, didn't want you messing with him, brushing him, nothing.  He would get mad if you just sat on him in 1 place too long.  He was just a jerk, which I alway assumed was his personality, but it wasn't.  He's so different now having been on these products and changed my program as Dr. Schell instructed me to.  It's the single most dramatic change i've ever seen in a horse, and while the respiratory improvement and repair is impressive, the most impressive part of this process for me is the change in my horse physically and mentally. 

My mom has been so blown away by it that she has also ordered the same product for her.  In a week, she has much less pain in her hands, her stomach problems have drastically improved, and she's been out riding every day with me instead of sleeping in her room.  Inflammation in the stomach and intestine can be linked to so many different ailments and diseases and can be the cause of systemic inflammation resulting in joint pain, allergies and asthma, IBS, and even cancer.  Heck, I even started taking a spoonful 2 spoonfuls of french's mustard myself, and i've yet to finish my first box of allergy medicine this year....and I typically can't go a day without it.  I'm next on the list to get myself some Cur-Ost, but as usual.....my horse's are higher on the priority list than me.  LOL
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
GLP
Reg. Oct 2013
Posted 2015-07-20 3:52 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


I just read the headlines


Posts: 4483
20002000100100100100252525
Herbie - 2015-07-20 3:46 PM

I am certainly no expert either, TurnLane, but in trying to find something to help my horse with his respiratory conditions, I began giving him french's mustard, and through that I did notice a very slight improvement in him after MONTHS and thousands of dollars spent on vets and drugs and supplements, etc.  I googled to find out what was in the French's and found turmeric, vinegar and water to be the only ingredients, so I then googled turmeric (curcurmin) and was blown away at all of the things I found in how it benefits people who consume it....things from treating IBS, to cancer, to arthritis, pain management, allergies, COPD, etc.....and not only is it just articles, but studies that document the progress of people taking curcurmin supplements.  In talking to one of my good friends about this, she said her mother and aunt take it for their RLS and they cured a very allergic/itchy dog with dermatitis in feeding it to the dog as well. 

I continued my google search but specified for horses and ran across the Cur-Ost company (www.nouvelleresearch.com) and began consulting with Dr. Schell on the issues with my horse, speaking primarily on the respiratory issues.  After about  weeks of him consulting with me (aka, me driving him crazy, i'm sure), I finally ordered the product.  Through the use of this product, I know that I know longer have a hind gut issue.  Even before this horse got sick, he has always been very irritable and very touchy where a back cinch would go.  He's always been very flinchy even when you brush him.  I've been through countless rounds of omeprazole, ranitidine, etc and while he would improve a little, these symptoms would never go away.  The change in this horse's attitude and overall well being is truly remarkable.  He has always been a little on the hateful side, didn't want you messing with him, brushing him, nothing.  He would get mad if you just sat on him in 1 place too long.  He was just a jerk, which I alway assumed was his personality, but it wasn't.  He's so different now having been on these products and changed my program as Dr. Schell instructed me to.  It's the single most dramatic change i've ever seen in a horse, and while the respiratory improvement and repair is impressive, the most impressive part of this process for me is the change in my horse physically and mentally. 

My mom has been so blown away by it that she has also ordered the same product for her.  In a week, she has much less pain in her hands, her stomach problems have drastically improved, and she's been out riding every day with me instead of sleeping in her room.  Inflammation in the stomach and intestine can be linked to so many different ailments and diseases and can be the cause of systemic inflammation resulting in joint pain, allergies and asthma, IBS, and even cancer.  Heck, I even started taking a spoonful 2 spoonfuls of french's mustard myself, and i've yet to finish my first box of allergy medicine this year....and I typically can't go a day without it.  I'm next on the list to get myself some Cur-Ost, but as usual.....my horse's are higher on the priority list than me.  LOL

How does your mother take it? I ordered some of their product and goodness, I have a very hard time downing it in juice. I have to use 2 bottles of juice to get it down. I know I am being a baby, but I have been thinking of adding it to smoothies.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
rodeomom3
Reg. Dec 2007
Posted 2015-07-20 3:57 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study



Shelter Dog Lover


Posts: 10277
50005000100100252525
lonely va barrelxr - 2015-07-20 1:28 PM
Herbie - 2015-07-20 1:06 PM Welllll....through the years I have fed probiotics and prebiotics and never saw a huge difference.  The prebiotics seemed to make my horses gassy.  The probiotics didn't make much difference at all.  I think that if we can eliminate the inflammation in the hind gut and maintain a healthy PH that we don't have the need for either and our horses are better for it.  I think we, as humans, and these horses being like our children, sometimes have a tendency to over-do it with trying to do the best we can for them and that in turn we often end up being counter productive through over feeding, over supplementing, and over medicating....this includes pro and prebiotics IMO. 

 






I like the way you think . .  

Me too. Let them be horses and try to feed them as them were meant to be fed. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-20 4:00 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
You're not a big baby!  She's mixes it with grape juice, ice, and water and puts it in a bottle with a screw top lid that she can't see through.  LOL  She drinks it while she's outside.  I see her grab it, give it a good shake, and take a swig....and this is from a woman who can't swallow a tylenol without a mouth full of chips and she still gags.  LOL  She says it was rough the first day or two but now she actually really likes it.  Pretty sure my horse felt exactly the same way.  HAHA YOU CAN DO IT, GLP!!!!!  But i'm thinking I may try to make a smoothie out of some of her mix tonight. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-20 4:02 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
Here is an article outlining the Leaky Gut issues in our horses (and ourselves) today and all of the things affected.  Some of you have probably already read this, but in case some of you haven't, i'll post it again.  
https://nouvelleresearch.com/index.php/articles/385-leaky-gut-syndrome-health-soundness 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
TurnLane
Reg. May 2007
Posted 2015-07-20 4:53 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study



Pork Fat is my Favorite


Posts: 3791
20001000500100100252525
Location: The Oklahoma plains.
Interesting, thanks for sharing. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
SG.
Reg. Sep 2003
Posted 2015-07-22 1:24 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Blessed
BHW Advertiser


50005000500050005000500050005000500050005000500050005000500100100100100252525
Location: Here

Thanks 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
total performance
Reg. Nov 2007
Posted 2015-07-22 1:38 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study



Namesless in BHW


Posts: 10368
500050001001001002525
Location: At the race track with Ah Dee Ohs
Herbie does lots of research and from our long conversations, she makes alot of sense.   
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
dsl
Reg. May 2007
Posted 2015-07-22 10:17 PM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Regular


Posts: 79
252525
Location: North Houston area
Great info. I have a horse very similar in personality to what you where describing. Have also tried several ulcer treatments. Which formula of the Cur-Ost worked for your horse?
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-23 8:40 AM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
dsl - 2015-07-22 10:17 PM Great info. I have a horse very similar in personality to what you where describing. Have also tried several ulcer treatments. Which formula of the Cur-Ost worked for your horse?

I was treating a severe respiratory condition when I started this program, so ulcers weren't even on the forefront of what I was concerned about at the time, the healing of the GI system and the overall change in my horse physically and mentally was an added bonus.  I would say if ulcers are the only think you're concerned with, the Total Support or the Stomach formula would be the way to gom probably the Total Support.  I'm still feeding the Immune & Repair, the Total Support, and the Adapt & Calm all three right now.  I've been told I could back off of the Immune & Repair but with as hot and dry as it is right now, i'm going to continue feeding it through the summer just to keep building up his immune system.   

I also changed my horses to whole oats once daily and alfalfa hay mixed with a little grass hay.  The artificial vit/min packs and the molasses are believed to be contributors to the inflammation in the GI system. 

 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
GLP
Reg. Oct 2013
Posted 2015-07-23 8:46 AM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


I just read the headlines


Posts: 4483
20002000100100100100252525
Herbie - 2015-07-23 8:40 AM

dsl - 2015-07-22 10:17 PM Great info. I have a horse very similar in personality to what you where describing. Have also tried several ulcer treatments. Which formula of the Cur-Ost worked for your horse?

I was treating a severe respiratory condition when I started this program, so ulcers weren't even on the forefront of what I was concerned about at the time, the healing of the GI system and the overall change in my horse physically and mentally was an added bonus.  I would say if ulcers are the only think you're concerned with, the Total Support or the Stomach formula would be the way to gom probably the Total Support.  I'm still feeding the Immune & Repair, the Total Support, and the Adapt & Calm all three right now.  I've been told I could back off of the Immune & Repair but with as hot and dry as it is right now, i'm going to continue feeding it through the summer just to keep building up his immune system.   

I also changed my horses to whole oats once daily and alfalfa hay mixed with a little grass hay.  The artificial vit/min packs and the molasses are believed to be contributors to the inflammation in the GI system. 

 

After reading about Herbie's horse, I contacted Dr. Schell about which Cur-Ost product to use on my ulcer prone horse. He replied within 24 hours, probably sooner. He had some questions which answered and then he told me what products to try and also how to improve my feeding regimen. Shoot him an email and he will get back with you as soon as he can. I have just started the 2 products he advised I try.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-23 9:07 AM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
Please keep us posted on your success!  I can't wait to hear about the difference in your horse. 

Here are just a few other thoughts to ponder in discussions i've had with Dr. Schell regarding feeds and feeding.  Thought it would be interesting to share.  Since changing my horse to whole oats once daily and alfalfa, he has bloomed even more and is almost tubby!  I was spending a small fortune on feed and feeding a full scoop, at least, twice daily at $28/bag.  With whole oats once daily and alfalfa, my feed bill has gone WAY down!

A friend of mine in our discussions about oats questioned why we sometimes see oats in our horses poop.  I'm not having this issue with my horses anymore, but certainly have in the past when feeding whole oats or whole flax.  This is the response I received:
"
“In regards to the Oats, this is no different than seeing other grains in the feces.  Yes, it can be a reflection of dental issues, also speed in which the horse consumes the grains (meaning they don't take time to enjoy the meal).  More so, I think it is also a reflection of bacterial imbalances within the hindgut and inability to digest fully cellulose and other plant materials.  We see this in various feces also where there is a lot of residual roughage such as stems in the feces as compared to more finer debris in more healthy patients.  This is why when we have a health or even lameness problem, looking at the feces can be a good indicator.
The EQ Total has really helped many of these horses due to benefits to the hindgut.  We also use the EQ Rejuventate to balance the microbes and in some, just plain brewer's yeast which improves cellulose digestion.
No grains in our horses feces either :)”

I also sent the information on the particular grain I was feeding to him for his opinion.  I was feeding this grain for probably the first 45 days I was giving the Cur-Ost as well, but decided to take my program one step further based on my consultations and try the whole oats and alfalfa as suggested.  Everything said here makes perfect sense to me, is backed by research and case studies, and is taking our horses back to basics of good quality forage and getting everything they need from whole foods or herbs rather than artificial ingredients.  This is the response to the grain I was feeding when I started the program.  Just more food for thought. 
“The feed is not bad, but there are some concerns from my perspective.  One of the biggest things that I look for is whole food supplying the nutrient load.  This means that if we are looking for magnesium, it is coming from food sources (as an example).  If you look at the list of ingredients, towards the mid section, you will see all of the artificial ingredients that are added...magnesium, zinc, calcium, vitamin E...the list goes on and on.  This means that the zinc or magnesium your horse is getting is in the artificial form, not natural or whole food.  Second, we have a lot of probiotics added to the feed.  Saccharomyces is okay, which is brewer's yeast, but then we have others such as lactobacillus being added.  The lactobacillus is one species we are seeing overgrown in our research project and in many other horses with clinical problems tying back to the gut.  I don't like these probiotics, as I feel they are possibly contributing to our inflammation issues, but then again, I am biased due to research. 
Again, there is no right or wrong.  To me, I'd rather put the money into a quality forage and use whole grain to accomplish what I am looking for in regards to grain usage.  In reality, the horses should really be about 90% dependent on forage and 10% dependent on grains. We only use grains as a medium for supplementation, plus some nutrition, but overall, they are not a huge part of our program. 
In regards to the probiotics, in equine medicine, there is actually very little data to support their use overall, aside from Saccharomyces which is brewer's yeast.  We actually use the brewer's yeast as part of our whole food supplement soon to be released as it helps to stabilize the bacterial levels in the hindgut and improves cellulose (plant) digestion...proven in equine studies.  The lactobacillus probiotics are researched on the human side, not the equine side.  In metabolics and laminitis cases, research has shown, in addition to our studies, that the lactobacillus levels are high, which is likely contributing to disease.  In today's equine world, the lactobacillus probiotics are used in feeds and in many supplements as secondary 'beneficial' ingredients.  I believe first that they are not needed.  Second, due to the high prevalence in supplements and in feeds, I think we are contributing to all ready high levels.  Not a good thing.  I have yet to encounter any horse owner that will tell you their stomach product with probiotics is helping any situation.  Despite this, they still give it as it is supposed to help the gut per the manufacturer.  This is profit driven marketing over health benefits.
For the whole grains, we use whole oats and whole barley.  Any form after this is 'processed' by definition and can impact nutrient levels and assimilation.  Nutritionists will tell you that horses cannot digest whole oats or even sunflower seeds without crushing their shells. This may be true in the hindgut deficient horse, but not in ours. “

 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
GLP
Reg. Oct 2013
Posted 2015-07-23 9:23 AM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


I just read the headlines


Posts: 4483
20002000100100100100252525
I must admit that it makes me nervous to adjust my feed to just oats, alfalfa and a little grass hay and limited turn out on grass. My horses are pretty much on dry lot right now until we can do some brush control. I am going to have my grass hay tested since the store I get it from only uses 1 source. The alfalfa hay we get here in South Texas is always really stemmy, so I am looking into going with the Omni cubes, but the nearest place to get them is 2 hours away. However, what I have been doing has not worked on 2 of my horses, so a change is needed. I am also having trouble letting go of my need to use a vitamin/mineral supplement, lol. But again, I am going to try Dr. Schell's advice as closely as possible. If anyone else tries this would you please keep us updated? I plan to update - to me this is very important stuff.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Herbie
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2015-07-23 9:49 AM
Subject: RE: Pre-biotics, Pro-biotics, or No-biotics....interesting read and study


Military family

Whack and Roll


Posts: 6342
5000100010010010025
Location: NE Texas
GLP - 2015-07-23 9:23 AM I must admit that it makes me nervous to adjust my feed to just oats, alfalfa and a little grass hay and limited turn out on grass. My horses are pretty much on dry lot right now until we can do some brush control. I am going to have my grass hay tested since the store I get it from only uses 1 source. The alfalfa hay we get here in South Texas is always really stemmy, so I am looking into going with the Omni cubes, but the nearest place to get them is 2 hours away. However, what I have been doing has not worked on 2 of my horses, so a change is needed. I am also having trouble letting go of my need to use a vitamin/mineral supplement, lol. But again, I am going to try Dr. Schell's advice as closely as possible. If anyone else tries this would you please keep us updated? I plan to update - to me this is very important stuff.

I hear ya, GLP, I am in Texas also and have one pasture that has some weedy grass in it, but the others are on dry lots mostly.  :)  Good forage is so difficult to get down here.  I have a friend who lives in LA and has this beautiful alfalfa trucked in every year.  Wish I could afford to do that as well....this stuff is gorgeous!  I was hesitantto make the change to oats but finally did it.  So glad I did and sure won't go back.  Getting the good quality forage and not relying so much on concentrate has just improved my program even more.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Jump to page :
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread
 

© Copyright 2002- BarrelHorseWorld.com All rights reserved including digital rights

Support - Contact / Log in to my account


Working Truck World Working Horse World Cargo Trailer World Horse Trailer World Roping Horse World
'
Registered to: Barrel Horse World
(Delete all cookies set by this site)
Running MegaBBS ASP Forum Software
© 2002-2026 PD9 Software