Log in to my account Barrel Horse World
Come on in Folks on-line

Today is

You are logged in as a guest. Logon or register an account to access more features.


Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!

Jump to page :
Last activity 2017-01-30 11:06 AM
46 replies, 8067 views

View previous thread :: View next thread
   General Discussion -> Barrel Talk
Refresh
 
iheartrodeo
Reg. Jun 2009
Posted 2017-01-04 11:27 AM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Veteran


Posts: 269
1001002525
I don't know much about FF. Dumb ?....So, if a stallion drops out of FF, what happens to their enrolled foals? Since their sire is no longer in the program are they no longer eligible for $ or are the foals enrolled for life no matter?



 

Edited by iheartrodeo 2017-01-04 11:29 AM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
mbcruel21
Reg. Jan 2004
Posted 2017-01-04 11:30 AM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



Color Coordination Director


5000200020005001002525
iheartrodeo - 2017-01-04 11:27 AM I don't know much about FF. Dumb ?....So, if a stallion drops out of FF, what happens to their enrolled foals? Since their sire is no longer in the program are they no longer eligible for $ or are the foals enrolled for life no matter?







 

 Once the foal is enrolled its good for life.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
casualdust07
Reg. Mar 2005
Posted 2017-01-04 11:30 AM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



You get what you give


Posts: 13030
500050002000100025
Location: Texas
iheartrodeo - 2017-01-04 11:27 AM

I don't know much about FF. Dumb ?....So, if a stallion drops out of FF, what happens to their enrolled foals? Since their sire is no longer in the program are they no longer eligible for $ or are the foals enrolled for life no matter?



 

If the foal was paid into FF, it stays in FF regardless if the stallion is in or leaves. It just means no new foals can be enrolled from a stallion that drops out.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
ThreeCorners
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2017-01-04 12:10 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family
Tried and True


Posts: 21185
50005000500050001000100252525
Location: Where I am happiest
 Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
mbcruel21
Reg. Jan 2004
Posted 2017-01-04 12:13 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



Color Coordination Director


5000200020005001002525
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM

 Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.

↑ Top ↓ Bottom
powerstroke power
Reg. Oct 2009
Posted 2017-01-04 12:43 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Extreme Veteran


Posts: 333
10010010025
mbcruel21 - 2017-01-04 12:13 PM

ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM

 Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.


I thought of this as well...If futurities are 4 years old (some are 5), wouldn't the stallion only need to enroll every 4 or 5 years? It'd be cheaper to nominate @ $500 for an older foal than to nominate a stallion each year. You could also pick which young horses seem more worthly of enrolling as they age.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
RHRanch
Reg. Sep 2004
Posted 2017-01-04 12:49 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



Expert


Posts: 1355
10001001001002525
powerstroke power - 2017-01-04 1:43 PM
mbcruel21 - 2017-01-04 12:13 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
I thought of this as well...If futurities are 4 years old (some are 5), wouldn't the stallion only need to enroll every 4 or 5 years? It'd be cheaper to nominate @ $500 for an older foal than to nominate a stallion each year. You could also pick which young horses seem more worthly of enrolling as they age.
There are quite a few  FF open races.

Edited by RHRanch 2017-01-04 12:50 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
tothebrim
Reg. Nov 2016
Posted 2017-01-04 1:21 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Regular


Posts: 84
252525
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 1:10 PM

 Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.

This is basically what I was trying to get at with my earlier statement, but your wording is much better than mine! I'm so glad someone feels the same! I dont think its going to go to crap quick... but i will be watching overtime to see how it all plays out.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
casualdust07
Reg. Mar 2005
Posted 2017-01-04 1:44 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



You get what you give


Posts: 13030
500050002000100025
Location: Texas
tothebrim - 2017-01-04 1:21 PM

ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 1:10 PM

 Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.

This is basically what I was trying to get at with my earlier statement, but your wording is much better than mine! I'm so glad someone feels the same! I dont think its going to go to crap quick... but i will be watching overtime to see how it all plays out.

The only things I will add are, there are plenty of cheap horses in FF now. There's plenty of small scale stallions that have been in FF whose babies do not sell for boat loads of money. There's plenty of stallions on there, that have been on there for years, that do not breed a lot of mares. There's even some on there who don't stand to the public. I don't think it's going to downgrade the quality of the horses in FF because there's already a huge range of horses in the program.

ETA- i wanted to make sure no one takes offense to the word cheap. Because, I don't mean cheap is bad. But it's true- there's a huge range of horses you can already buy that are PIF to future fortunes that sell for under 5k. Doesn't make them bad either, just saying that it's never been just elite stallions selling super pricey babies.

Edited by casualdust07 2017-01-04 1:49 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
ThreeCorners
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2017-01-04 1:56 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family
Tried and True


Posts: 21185
50005000500050001000100252525
Location: Where I am happiest
casualdust07 - 2017-01-04 1:44 PM
tothebrim - 2017-01-04 1:21 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 1:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
This is basically what I was trying to get at with my earlier statement, but your wording is much better than mine! I'm so glad someone feels the same! I dont think its going to go to crap quick... but i will be watching overtime to see how it all plays out.
The only things I will add are, there are plenty of cheap horses in FF now. There's plenty of small scale stallions that have been in FF whose babies do not sell for boat loads of money. There's plenty of stallions on there, that have been on there for years, that do not breed a lot of mares. There's even some on there who don't stand to the public. I don't think it's going to downgrade the quality of the horses in FF because there's already a huge range of horses in the program. ETA- i wanted to make sure no one takes offense to the word cheap. Because, I don't mean cheap is bad. But it's true- there's a huge range of horses you can already buy that are PIF to future fortunes that sell for under 5k. Doesn't make them bad either, just saying that it's never been just elite stallions selling super pricey babies.

I believe you misunderstood what I meant by cheap horses. I probably didnt clarify well as I was typing on my phone. lol. By cheap horses I meant horses jumping in for one year for a one time enrollment fee just to get all that horses foals in, some will be older horses, and then dropping out. Collecting checks year after year but only contributing to the pot one time. OR, stallions jumping in and out every five years or so , contributing very little compared to stallions who stay enrolled every year. Plus, if now all older foals even from previously enrolled stallions can get in for $500, then they to have jumped in cheap, contributing little to the pot. Thus really, cheapening the whole program. Thats what I meant by cheap. Hope that clarified it.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
casualdust07
Reg. Mar 2005
Posted 2017-01-04 2:00 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



You get what you give


Posts: 13030
500050002000100025
Location: Texas
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 1:56 PM

casualdust07 - 2017-01-04 1:44 PM
tothebrim - 2017-01-04 1:21 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 1:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
This is basically what I was trying to get at with my earlier statement, but your wording is much better than mine! I'm so glad someone feels the same! I dont think its going to go to crap quick... but i will be watching overtime to see how it all plays out.
The only things I will add are, there are plenty of cheap horses in FF now. There's plenty of small scale stallions that have been in FF whose babies do not sell for boat loads of money. There's plenty of stallions on there, that have been on there for years, that do not breed a lot of mares. There's even some on there who don't stand to the public. I don't think it's going to downgrade the quality of the horses in FF because there's already a huge range of horses in the program. ETA- i wanted to make sure no one takes offense to the word cheap. Because, I don't mean cheap is bad. But it's true- there's a huge range of horses you can already buy that are PIF to future fortunes that sell for under 5k. Doesn't make them bad either, just saying that it's never been just elite stallions selling super pricey babies.

I believe you misunderstood what I meant by cheap horses. I probably didnt clarify well as I was typing on my phone. lol. By cheap horses I meant horses jumping in for one year for a one time enrollment fee just to get all that horses foals in, some will be older horses, and then dropping out. Collecting checks year after year but only contributing to the pot one time. OR, stallions jumping in and out every five years or so , contributing very little compared to stallions who stay enrolled every year. Plus, if now all older foals even from previously enrolled stallions can get in for $500, then they to have jumped in cheap, contributing little to the pot. Thus really, cheapening the whole program. Thats what I meant by cheap. Hope that clarified it.

yeah that clarifies it!! I could be wrong, because some of this stuff is confusing, but i thought they were grandfathering horses in 2018 one time for 500 and after that wouldn't allow that deal on grandfathering??? But again, I could be soooo wrong!

And that does pose the question on whether they will allow a horse to sporadically enroll, un-enroll, then re-enroll or if they will not allow a horse to re-enroll after they pull out, unless they change owners. That would be a way to play the system for sure.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Whiteboy
Reg. Jul 2012
Posted 2017-01-04 2:24 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family

That's White "Man" to You


Posts: 5515
5000500
evf - 2017-01-04 11:24 AM
Whiteboy - 2017-01-04 10:51 AM The ones I feel bad for are all the fools that just forked over $10,000 for their FF spot.  Haha.  
Can you explain this to me. I'm not very familiar with how FF works. Who pays 10,000 for what?

Prior to this new anouncement the only way to get a stallion into FF was to wait your turn or buy an existing spot.  Those spots that sold, sold for BIG money.  FF had a rule in place that they could be sold for no more than $2,800 if I remember right but they had no way to monitor or penalize if someone did something different.  So in essense it was a "black market" to participate in the incentive.  
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Barrelhorsehelp1
Reg. Jan 2014
Posted 2017-01-04 2:39 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!




1001001002525
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM

 Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.

EXACTLY! what a shame just any and every horse can be FF now.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
TheOldGrayMare
Reg. Nov 2009
Posted 2017-01-04 2:46 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



Expert


Posts: 4625
2000200050010025
Location: Desert Land
Barrelhorsehelp1 - 2017-01-04 12:39 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
EXACTLY! what a shame just any and every horse can be FF now.

Well that's a little exaggerated. The foal would have to be by a FF stallion to enroll....you can't just pay in because you want to join the club.
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
mbcruel21
Reg. Jan 2004
Posted 2017-01-04 3:06 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



Color Coordination Director


5000200020005001002525
TheOldGrayMare - 2017-01-04 2:46 PM
Barrelhorsehelp1 - 2017-01-04 12:39 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
EXACTLY! what a shame just any and every horse can be FF now.
Well that's a little exaggerated. The foal would have to be by a FF stallion to enroll....you can't just pay in because you want to join the club.
I think what ThreeCorners is trying to say is there are stallions out there that are lets say 20 and have 150 foals, they can pay that stallion in for one year and all of those foals can be grandfathered in for $200 a piece and then they can drop him after the first year. So 150 foals are FF eligible now at the intro rate, the stallion paid in ONE year and they are running for the money that the other stallion owners have paid in every year.

Edited by mbcruel21 2017-01-04 3:12 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
ThreeCorners
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2017-01-04 3:14 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family
Tried and True


Posts: 21185
50005000500050001000100252525
Location: Where I am happiest
mbcruel21 - 2017-01-04 3:06 PM
TheOldGrayMare - 2017-01-04 2:46 PM
Barrelhorsehelp1 - 2017-01-04 12:39 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
EXACTLY! what a shame just any and every horse can be FF now.
Well that's a little exaggerated. The foal would have to be by a FF stallion to enroll....you can't just pay in because you want to join the club.
I think what ThreeCorners is trying to say is there are stallions out there that are lets say 20 and have 150 foals, they can pay that stallion in for one year and all of those foals can be grandfathered in for $200 a piece and then they can drop him after the first year. So 150 foals are FF eligible now at the intro rate, the stallion paid in ONE year and they are running for the money that the other stallion owners have paid in every year.

 EXACTLY!!! 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
wyoming barrel racer
Reg. Apr 2006
Posted 2017-01-04 3:21 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family

Neat Freak


Posts: 11216
500050001000100100
Location: Wonderful Wyoming
I can answer 2 questions asked here, I just read a lot of what the FF founder put on facebook. It says in the first post when you can enroll new stallions-Nomination dates for NEW Stallions only will be from March 15 - May 15 of the year prior to enrollment.

And once you enroll a stallion, if you choose to let him drop out, you can NEVER re enroll him. So that won't be an issue. There will be kinks to any program, but this will eliminate the BS that came with the waiting list. I saw more and more yearlings- coming 2 yr olds newly enrolled at the same time  I saw friends with stallions waiting 10+ yrs. The stallion list kept growing...and even though I know a "few" people dropped out, not enough to watch #'s grow with youngsters when others waited a decade to get in.

I said it on facebook, this isn't going to change much. You'll have every Tom Dick & Harry enroll their stallion. Some will be good, some not so much. Many will drop when they aren't seeing an increase in mares coming to their romeo. The point is this!! If a stallion isn't already manly enough to get a full book of mares, enrolling him in incentives will not help. The point of incentives is to make it worth it to those people that are paying high stud fees and paying top dollar for those babies, to have a way to win some of that back (FF, Breeders Futurities etc). 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
wyoming barrel racer
Reg. Apr 2006
Posted 2017-01-04 3:32 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family

Neat Freak


Posts: 11216
500050001000100100
Location: Wonderful Wyoming
mbcruel21 - 2017-01-04 11:13 AM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.

those hundreds of cheap horses enrolling for $500 will not change anything. If they were cheap, 99% of them will never make it to a top trainer (or a trainer for that matter) and if people can't afford a better prospect, they certainly won't pay then up into futurities. This doesn't mean that you won't occasionally have that good home grown horse, self trained that wins at the elite level. But lets me honest-look back at last yrs Futurity horses/trainers/owners. They are the same ones that buy, train & enter every year. The same top sires are leading year after year. We all know these are not cheap horses. DTF is not FF and can not be-he is deceased. Just because Joe down the road has his $500 stud enrolled in  FF by Doc Bars Mr Doc Bar, and pays all his 4 & 5 yr olds up at $500 doesn't mean 1 of them will ever run for FF money. It won't spread the $$$ pot. If anything you will see an increase in FF money these next 2-3 yrs before people realize it is not cost effective when only covering 5-10 mares a year. Remember stallion owners only get a small % of the FF pot.

And this comes from someone that doesn't stand a stallion and I have no intention of paying one up in FF anytime soon. I breed to one that is in FF. I assist with his advertising and can say that enrolling in FF didn't bring him more mares. He was already live covering 20+ mares as well as what he ships to. But it did increase his foal value...this is because he is already a proven stallion and still competing, a proven sire from his first foal crop. Bottom line, he was already a nice stallion. People were breeding to him and buying his babies. This just makes them willing to pay a little more. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
wyoming barrel racer
Reg. Apr 2006
Posted 2017-01-04 3:37 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!


Military family

Neat Freak


Posts: 11216
500050001000100100
Location: Wonderful Wyoming
casualdust07 - 2017-01-04 9:41 AM
mbcruel21 - 2017-01-04 10:29 AM
casualdust07 - 2017-01-04 10:13 AM People used to complain that FF was an insider "club" where people who had connections could get their stallion in when others had to wait 5 years or whatever on the wait list. Those same people now complain that FF is open to everyone.. Which I mean, if I had to wait 5 years to get into a club and then now that I'm in everyone else gets to come in too, I would probably be a little upset over it. But, I also think that's a bit childish to want to stay exclusive now that you're in the "club" since it was hard for you to get in and now your friends can get in without waiting. As a mare owner and breeder, I am thrilled that it is open for everyone now. There were times when I scrolled and scrolled on the FF website looking for something new or fresh. Some stallion owners have complained that after having joined FF, their books haven't increased at all. But in my opinion, FF is only one part of what makes a stallion desirable.
Since I am sure this was directed about my post, I am going to add my opinion. The issue that I have is yes we waited our time, 9 yrs to be exact, when the spot was offered we had to take it, knowing that our stallion was not going to have babies old enough to run for 5 years.... 5 years multiplied by $2500...that is $12,500 that has been paid into out of pocket because we HAD to take the spot or we would lose the option. Then lets add the fact that most people have no idea that the stallion owners are funding this program at over $600,000 a year coming from stallion owners we only get a return of 10%, which from everyone I have talked to is actually less that ONE PERCENT on rate of return for the stallion owners.  Every stallion owner that has a spot did it to because it makes the babies worth a small percentage more, thats is the ONLY return we get it on our investment. We sure as heck dont get any thank yous for spending tens of thousands of dollars so that the colts and whom ever owns them at the time they are competing get that extra money.  Future Fortunes is a wonderful program for the people who own the offspring, it doesnt pay like a slot machine for the stallion owners  contrary to what every seems to think. Stallion owners put their horses in these programs to please the mare owners and the people who are running the babies. We do it because we believe in our horse and his ability to produce something that is successful.  
I did read your post but I have seen many posts about FF over the past couple of years and from talking to stallion owners themselves about whether to pay in or not so I wasn't directing anything at you personally. I'm not a stallion owner, so I look at breeder incentives on what they can do for me- a breeder and owner of the colts, not on the stallion side of things. I'm sure my opinion may be different if it affected me in a different way. I don't think Future Fortunes was ever designed to benefit stallion owners more than other facets of the market, it was designed to pay out the owners of the competing horses. The other incentive programs tend to favor the stallion owner over the breeder. FF pays the owner of the horse 70%, then breeder 20% then stallion owner 10% Triple Crown places the stallion owner over the breeder And then BBR select stallion stakes, from what it looks like, only pays the owner of the foal and the stallion owner.
This is a good explanation. 

Edited by wyoming barrel racer 2017-01-04 5:50 PM
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
TheOldGrayMare
Reg. Nov 2009
Posted 2017-01-04 4:40 PM
Subject: RE: Future Fortunes Announcement!! Changes to stallion enrollment!



Expert


Posts: 4625
2000200050010025
Location: Desert Land
mbcruel21 - 2017-01-04 1:06 PM
TheOldGrayMare - 2017-01-04 2:46 PM
Barrelhorsehelp1 - 2017-01-04 12:39 PM
ThreeCorners - 2017-01-04 12:10 PM  Being the analytical mind I have, the more I thought about this the more I think this could be a very bad thing. I do feel for the horses that waited on the list, and those that have paid in when their stallions were very young to fork over thousands knowing they had to wait years to even start to see a return. Now any Tom Dick and Harry can jump in. Also with the $200 foal enrollment and first year enrollment, and then changing older horses that didnt enroll as foals at a stallions first year for next year $500. There will be hundreds of cheap enrolled horses now in spreading the pot thinner and thinner. I could see stallions, like old horses still alive enrolling 1 year, getting their older foals in and dropping out. I can see stallions enrolling one year, drop out, waiting a couple years and enrolling again. Spreading the pot thinner and thinner yet not contributing much. I sure will be watching to see what they do with this. They need to add clauses once a horse drops out he's out forever. They should probably also add clauses that a stallion must breed 10? or so mares a year to sustain. Other wise, really, what is the prestige of having a FF horse when they will be on every street corner earning peanuts. Just some thoughts running through my mind.
EXACTLY! what a shame just any and every horse can be FF now.
Well that's a little exaggerated. The foal would have to be by a FF stallion to enroll....you can't just pay in because you want to join the club.
I think what ThreeCorners is trying to say is there are stallions out there that are lets say 20 and have 150 foals, they can pay that stallion in for one year and all of those foals can be grandfathered in for $200 a piece and then they can drop him after the first year. So 150 foals are FF eligible now at the intro rate, the stallion paid in ONE year and they are running for the money that the other stallion owners have paid in every year.

I totally understood ThreeCorners and agree! I just thought Barrelhorsehelp1 was being a bit dramatic. 
↑ Top ↓ Bottom
Jump to page :
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread
 

© Copyright 2002- BarrelHorseWorld.com All rights reserved including digital rights

Support - Contact / Log in to my account


Working Truck World Working Horse World Cargo Trailer World Horse Trailer World Roping Horse World
'
Registered to: Barrel Horse World
(Delete all cookies set by this site)
Running MegaBBS ASP Forum Software
© 2002-2026 PD9 Software