|
|
 A Barrel Of Monkeys
Posts: 12972
          Location: Texas | FlyinDoveHorses - 2015-03-07 12:13 AM He's been doing cutting roping barrels poles. He's doing amazing down here in TXLA, just got home and he took 1st in the 2D tonight with only his 6th time out with 100 in the open. He packing plenty under the hood. He throws roans so far with limited crop. OF COURSE he has been tested we did that when I bought him... I have good friends that have crossed their Paints with thoroughbreds and they have been doing exceptionally well for a long time. IM going to cross these two, yes I have nice QH/Paints booked and some in foal now. Market might not be there but when the foal is winning and the sire then it won't be crazy. I will eventually cross the offspring of this cross with a higher or "designer " line. Right now I'm focusing on a few outside mares and getting him really winning. Everyone that has met him, seen him they wanna breed no matter what he's registered or what the baby looks like(color). I know it's gonna be hard but hell do it and he'll stay intact. Why geld something that is exceptional. I know sounds crazy but yAll will see ;) Thank for all yAlls input positive or not. :-)
There is no way this horse is exceptional - just by virtue of his breeding and the fact that he is a solid bred paint. Sorry. | |
| | |

| Love Northern Dancer and I would not have a Storm Cat | |
| | |
  Northern Chocolate Queen
Posts: 16576
        Location: ND | Your stallion is a horse I would LOVE to ride but imo is not a marketable sire. Having Impressive in his pedigree is a big red check mark to most barrel racers, they won't give them a second glance and many hate Two Eyed Jack as well. People are very undeducated on HYPP and therefore avoid Impressive completely and this will really hurt your sale value of foals. I've had great luck with TEJ horses & love my gelding that goes back to Impressive so your horse carrying both of those lines as well as the other nice old blood actually apeals to me but I'm by far in the minority as I want versatile horses, not specialized for one event.
I'm another that would not breed him to a TB. If you want speed I'd find a nice running bred QH mare instead. I know some TB's do make it in the barrel pen but not the majority. If I was shopping & looking at a foal by your stallion I'd want to see it out of a QH or Paint mare bred similar to him with lots or old lines and real solid conformation.....but again I'm the minority in this world!
I won't jump on the geld him bandwagon as we all like something different and there is no harm in breeding and raising what YOU like for yourself. Just don't go into it thinking you are going to sell these foals for big money or have pile of outside mares booked. The majority of people will not give a basically unproven, solid sorrel Paint with an unpopular pedigree a second glance. | |
| | |
  Fact Checker
Posts: 16575
        Location: Displaced Iowegian | This thread just proves the point of why there are so many horses available for the slaughter trucks...... | |
| | |
 Tried and True
Posts: 21185
         Location: Where I am happiest | Sadly, this is so true. I saw on facebook this morning there are 3 nice bred mares going through Eugene Oregon horse auction today. That is a cheap local horse auction full of kill buyers. These mares, are sired by a direct son of Easy Jet with a SI of 102 and out of a Chicks Deck daughter!! You cant get pedigree like that, that close anymore and the oldest one is 15. I fear for them going to slaughter.
Edited by ThreeCorners 2015-03-08 12:58 PM
| |
| | |
 A Somebody to Everybody
Posts: 41354
              Location: Under The Big Sky Of Texas | ThreeCorners - 2015-03-08 12:57 PM Sadly, this is so true. I saw on facebook this morning there are 3 nice bred mares going through Eugene Oregon horse auction today. That is a cheap local horse auction full of kill buyers. These mares, are sired by a direct son of Easy Jet with a SI of 102 and out of a Chicks Deck daughter!! You cant get pedigree like that, that close anymore and the oldest one is 15. I fear for them going to slaughter. How sad, Sometimes I feel like I need to go to the auction so that I can resuce a few thats going to slaughter, I have the pasture but worried I might go over board, there is just so many out there. Some really nice babys going threw a few years back friend bought one and I tracked down the selling and he gave me the papers to fill out to get him reg. nice baby and some really decent blood going threw him. Pay 60.00 bucks for him.
Edited by Southtxponygirl 2015-03-08 1:08 PM
| |
| | |
 Tried and True
Posts: 21185
         Location: Where I am happiest | Southtxponygirl - 2015-03-08 1:07 PM ThreeCorners - 2015-03-08 12:57 PM Sadly, this is so true. I saw on facebook this morning there are 3 nice bred mares going through Eugene Oregon horse auction today. That is a cheap local horse auction full of kill buyers. These mares, are sired by a direct son of Easy Jet with a SI of 102 and out of a Chicks Deck daughter!! You cant get pedigree like that, that close anymore and the oldest one is 15. I fear for them going to slaughter. How sad, Sometimes I feel like I need to go to the auction so that I can resuce a few thats going to slaughter, I have the pasture but worried I might go over board, there is just so many out there. Some really nice babys going threw a few years back friend bought one and I tracked down the selling and he gave me the papers to fill out to get him reg. nice baby and some really decent blood going threw him. Pay 60.00 bucks for him.
I hear ya. I saw the pics of those mares and they are nice mares. I was really tempted but the timing for us is terrible. It's looking like my husband is going to have to have surgery on his neck so that will put him off work for months and we have just started a remodel and facelift on our house so we can sell it. If there wasnt so much uncertainty right now, I would so be picking up the phone to bid. | |
| | |
Elite Veteran
Posts: 898
       Location: Mountains of VA | Let's flip this situation around..........let's say the op's stallion is a mare.......solid sorrel/chestnut APHA paint with the same bloodlines. What stallion would you breed her to that would most compliment her and make her foals marketable??
1st, a paint should have color, breed her to a homozygous tobiano. As it is, all the foals will have to be reg. as breeding stock Paints only unless you get color and "she" will not produce color bred to a QH or TB.
2nd, compliment her conformation.........a larger, leaner, less muscled foal will be more marketable in a variety of disciplines.......a close to 16H tobiano stud with TB looks, big sweeping stride, shorter back, etc. , would work.
3rd, bloodlines.........personally, the bloodlines that would compliment the best would be WP or Halter but a strong race-bred pedigree "might" help sell the foal into a performance home, otherwise, the foals are going to have to get started under saddle and show that they can be marketable as a performance horse. So, it will they will be 3 or 4 years old to advertise. Will they be able to be priced high enough to invest the time and upkeep until sold??
Just offering another point of view. | |
| | |
 Bulls Eye
Posts: 6443
       Location: Oklahoma | As a fellow stallion owner and one who has been around the Thoroughbred breeding farms, I wouldn't breed to a Storm Cat. The majority of them are crooked in the legs and their temperaments aren't exactly desirable. If you do go for the thoroughbred mares, look for mares with sprinting pedigrees.
I wouldn't breed to a solid bred paint, but that is me, unless I had a mare that was loud marked and homozygous for throwing colored foals. I highly recommend doing your research before you offer him to the public.
Like I said, I have stallion too and in my eyes he's fantastic in every way, but I don't advertise him and I am in the process of trying to prove him. | |
| | |
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 490
      
| In the TB's defense......
Ive seen the her. She is built like a QH. Big, soggy mare with a great attitude. And Ive seen a few out of her. I believe one is going to be futuritied. So the mare does produce good looking babies. | |
| | |
 Jr. Detective
      Location: Beggs, OK | Jazz's Girl - 2015-03-09 9:33 AM In the TB's defense...... Ive seen the her. She is built like a QH. Big, soggy mare with a great attitude. And Ive seen a few out of her. I believe one is going to be futuritied. So the mare does produce good looking babies.
If the mare is 7, when did she start having babies? She has some running in futurities already...supposedly. Why not breed her to something that would compliment her and produce better than her instead of a "stud" that you're trying to improve on? | |
| | |
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 490
      
| I can't answer that because I don't know. Ive seen the mare. Shes a good looking horse.
I wish the OP the best in whatever she chooses to do with her horses. | |
| | |
 Peecans
       
| hotpaints - 2015-03-09 6:34 AM
Let's flip this situation around..........let's say the op's stallion is a mare.......solid sorrel/chestnut APHA paint with the same bloodlines. What stallion would you breed her to that would most compliment her and make her foals marketable??
1st, a paint should have color, breed her to a homozygous tobiano. As it is, all the foals will have to be reg. as breeding stock Paints only unless you get color and "she" will not produce color bred to a QH or TB.
2nd, compliment her conformation.........a larger, leaner, less muscled foal will be more marketable in a variety of disciplines.......a close to 16H tobiano stud with TB looks, big sweeping stride, shorter back, etc. , would work.
3rd, bloodlines.........personally, the bloodlines that would compliment the best would be WP or Halter but a strong race-bred pedigree "might" help sell the foal into a performance home, otherwise, the foals are going to have to get started under saddle and show that they can be marketable as a performance horse. So, it will they will be 3 or 4 years old to advertise. Will they be able to be priced high enough to invest the time and upkeep until sold??
Just offering another point of view. Â
Your first point, a paint HAS to have color is exactly why the paint horses have a pad rap ad being a color breed and inferior to a quarter horse because the breeders focus on color.
That stigma i doubt will ever change, I personaly feel theres nothing wrong with a solid paint, and IF and i mean IF the stud had the breeding and build and preformance in the areana and breeding shed that worked with my mare color is the last thing on my mind.
It just makes me sad that great mares will get breed down to improve color, even if a nice colored stud is avaible many will skip him for a homozygous one to guarantee color, even if the heterozygous was the better cross. | |
| | |
 Scorpions R Us
Posts: 9586
       Location: So. Cali. | ThreeCorners - 2015-03-06 2:58 PM I'm not opposed to breeding TB mares at all. Alot of very nice, very successful horses have come from TB mares and we should never forget what Three Bars did for the QH breed. Also, nobody can tell me TB's cant run barrels because I have known a few bang up TB barrel horses. The most recient is Jandee Smart's BCR Stella Bella. She is tuff tuff tuff on that horse and qualified to The American this year. Unfortunatelly tipped a barrel with a 14.9 in the long go. That said, I am not a fan at all with Storm Cat horses. I didnt look at the pedigree of your mare so I have no clue how far back he is. The further the better as far as I am concerned and honestly, I dont know a single one who has made it in the barrel pen. Maybe someone else knows of one? Thats not to say she isnt a nice individual herself and she may even be a great producer. She will obviously tell her own story.
As far as your stallion goes, he is a BS paint. Not alot of marketability there. He looks like a nice horse, but he is in all honesty not packing alot of selling points for building a breeding program around. There wont be much marketability in his foals unless you make it to the NFR on him or go win The American. He will have to really rattle peoples cage and do it many times to create a demand for his foals. Only because he isnt packing a stacked pedigree by being a direct son of a big name hall of famer type horse and he has no color. No color is great, IF they arent a paint. I 100% agree with the above though, if you really want to build a breeding program around this horse, then you are going to have to get some colored race mares under him so you at least have a chance at not going broke. It really is darn near impossible to re-invent the wheel. I'm not trying to be harsh, just honest. The horse business is whats harsh.
I have to correct you here. I heard the announcer at the American say she was a TB as well claimed off the track for the TB makeover by Jandee and her mom. However, I can not find a TB registered as a BCR Stella Bella. Instead I found a 2003 Appendix that did indeed race. Sire was a full TB, however the dam is a daughter of Dash Ta Fame that also goes back to Easy Jet and Rebs Policy. I believe that was a mistake on the announcers part...
| |
| | |
  That's White "Man" to You
Posts: 5515
 
| Three*C*Champs - 2015-03-09 11:49 AM ThreeCorners - 2015-03-06 2:58 PM I'm not opposed to breeding TB mares at all. Alot of very nice, very successful horses have come from TB mares and we should never forget what Three Bars did for the QH breed. Also, nobody can tell me TB's cant run barrels because I have known a few bang up TB barrel horses. The most recient is Jandee Smart's BCR Stella Bella. She is tuff tuff tuff on that horse and qualified to The American this year. Unfortunatelly tipped a barrel with a 14.9 in the long go. That said, I am not a fan at all with Storm Cat horses. I didnt look at the pedigree of your mare so I have no clue how far back he is. The further the better as far as I am concerned and honestly, I dont know a single one who has made it in the barrel pen. Maybe someone else knows of one? Thats not to say she isnt a nice individual herself and she may even be a great producer. She will obviously tell her own story.
As far as your stallion goes, he is a BS paint. Not alot of marketability there. He looks like a nice horse, but he is in all honesty not packing alot of selling points for building a breeding program around. There wont be much marketability in his foals unless you make it to the NFR on him or go win The American. He will have to really rattle peoples cage and do it many times to create a demand for his foals. Only because he isnt packing a stacked pedigree by being a direct son of a big name hall of famer type horse and he has no color. No color is great, IF they arent a paint. I 100% agree with the above though, if you really want to build a breeding program around this horse, then you are going to have to get some colored race mares under him so you at least have a chance at not going broke. It really is darn near impossible to re-invent the wheel. I'm not trying to be harsh, just honest. The horse business is whats harsh.
I have to correct you here. I heard the announcer at the American say she was a TB as well claimed off the track for the TB makeover by Jandee and her mom. However, I can not find a TB registered as a BCR Stella Bella. Instead I found a 2003 Appendix that did indeed race. Sire was a full TB, however the dam is a daughter of Dash Ta Fame that also goes back to Easy Jet and Rebs Policy. I believe that was a mistake on the announcers part...
Loved the BCR horses. Lots of rebs policy and kingdom key! What a great program, sure wish they were still producing some horses! | |
| | |
Expert
Posts: 1611
  
| rachellyn80 - 2015-03-09 11:43 AM Jazz's Girl - 2015-03-09 9:33 AM In the TB's defense...... Ive seen the her. She is built like a QH. Big, soggy mare with a great attitude. And Ive seen a few out of her. I believe one is going to be futuritied. So the mare does produce good looking babies. If the mare is 7, when did she start having babies? Â She has some running in futurities already...supposedly. Â Why not breed her to something that would compliment her and produce better than her instead of a "stud" that you're trying to improve on?
The fact that this had to be pointed out totally tells us all he needs to be a gelding...Â
Sorry I'm a fan of the "geld them all club" and I don't care how "exceptional" people think their studs are, they would all make amazing geldings. Â WAYYYYYYY too many sons of DTF, FG, FWF, and now even SOF Â that need to be geldings. IMO if you can not market the stud the way he deserves, you don't have a facility set up to breed nor have the money to send your stud to be collected/stay at a breeding farm, your not concerned with proving him on the track/in the arena, and your not breeding to better the breed then you have NO business breeding. Â Breeding was designed to improve animals... Â Â
Edited by astreakinchic 2015-03-09 12:39 PM
| |
| | |
  Champ
Posts: 19623
       Location: Peg-Leg Julia Grimm | della - 2015-03-09 8:59 AM hotpaints - 2015-03-09 6:34 AM Let's flip this situation around..........let's say the op's stallion is a mare.......solid sorrel/chestnut APHA paint with the same bloodlines. What stallion would you breed her to that would most compliment her and make her foals marketable??
1st, a paint should have color, breed her to a homozygous tobiano. As it is, all the foals will have to be reg. as breeding stock Paints only unless you get color and "she" will not produce color bred to a QH or TB.
2nd, compliment her conformation.........a larger, leaner, less muscled foal will be more marketable in a variety of disciplines.......a close to 16H tobiano stud with TB looks, big sweeping stride, shorter back, etc. , would work.
3rd, bloodlines.........personally, the bloodlines that would compliment the best would be WP or Halter but a strong race-bred pedigree "might" help sell the foal into a performance home, otherwise, the foals are going to have to get started under saddle and show that they can be marketable as a performance horse. So, it will they will be 3 or 4 years old to advertise. Will they be able to be priced high enough to invest the time and upkeep until sold??
Just offering another point of view.
Your first point, a paint HAS to have color is exactly why the paint horses have a pad rap ad being a color breed and inferior to a quarter horse because the breeders focus on color. That stigma i doubt will ever change, I personaly feel theres nothing wrong with a solid paint, and IF and i mean IF the stud had the breeding and build and preformance in the areana and breeding shed that worked with my mare color is the last thing on my mind. It just makes me sad that great mares will get breed down to improve color, even if a nice colored stud is avaible many will skip him for a homozygous one to guarantee color, even if the heterozygous was the better cross.
If you don't want a COLORED paint (because that's what "paint" means), then buy a quarter horse or a morgan/arab cross. APHA only registers horses that are of APHA, AQHA and TB descent because they are a stock horse type. They are NOT a breed. They are a color and type. And only a type because they don't want arab, draft or gaited horses in their registry. They started out pintos because of color only. They've been bred UP for several decades by breeding them to AQHA and TB horses. That makes them as good in a lot of cases as a quarter horse in performance. BUT they are still a color registry. If people keep breeding solid paints to horses with no chance of getting color back in, they lose the color unless they are crossed back to a colored paint. Why bother with APHA at all? Just buy a quarter horse.
Trust me, I don't breed FOR color. But I had a paint mare I grew up riding. Paints are suppose to have spots. If you lose the spots you breed back to something with spots. And don't tell me there are no REALLY nice paint studs. There are even some REALLY nice homozygous paint studs. You may have to ship semen from them, but they exist. For those that think color doesn't matter then why not try for the color of the breed of horse you own? If you don't get it, nothing lost. | |
| | |
 Peecans
       
| OregonBR - 2015-03-09 11:12 AM
della - 2015-03-09 8:59 AM hotpaints - 2015-03-09 6:34 AM Let's flip this situation around..........let's say the op's stallion is a mare.......solid sorrel/chestnut APHA paint with the same bloodlines. What stallion would you breed her to that would most compliment her and make her foals marketable??
1st, a paint should have color, breed her to a homozygous tobiano. As it is, all the foals will have to be reg. as breeding stock Paints only unless you get color and "she" will not produce color bred to a QH or TB.
2nd, compliment her conformation.........a larger, leaner, less muscled foal will be more marketable in a variety of disciplines.......a close to 16H tobiano stud with TB looks, big sweeping stride, shorter back, etc. , would work.
3rd, bloodlines.........personally, the bloodlines that would compliment the best would be WP or Halter but a strong race-bred pedigree "might" help sell the foal into a performance home, otherwise, the foals are going to have to get started under saddle and show that they can be marketable as a performance horse. So, it will they will be 3 or 4 years old to advertise. Will they be able to be priced high enough to invest the time and upkeep until sold??
Just offering another point of view.
 Your first point, a paint HAS to have color is exactly why the paint horses have a pad rap ad being a color breed and inferior to a quarter horse because the breeders focus on color. That stigma i doubt will ever change, I personaly feel theres nothing wrong with a solid paint, and IF and i mean IF the stud had the breeding and build and preformance in the areana and breeding shed that worked with my mare color is the last thing on my mind. It just makes me sad that great mares will get breed down to improve color, even if a nice colored stud is avaible many will skip him for a homozygous one to guarantee color, even if the heterozygous was the better cross.
 If you don't want a COLORED paint (because that's what "paint" means), then buy a quarter horse or a morgan/arab cross. APHA only registers horses that are of APHA, AQHA and TB descent because they are a stock horse type.  They are NOT a breed. They are a color and type. And only a type because they don't want arab, draft or gaited horses in their registry.  They started out pintos because of color only. They've been bred UP for several decades by breeding them to AQHA and TB horses.  That makes them as good in a lot of cases as a quarter horse in performance. BUT they are still a color registry. If people keep breeding solid paints to horses with no chance of getting color back in, they lose the color unless they are crossed back to a colored paint.  Why bother with APHA at all? Just buy a quarter horse. Â
Trust me, I don't breed FOR color. But I had a paint mare I grew up riding. Â Paints are suppose to have spots. Â If you lose the spots you breed back to something with spots. And don't tell me there are no REALLY nice paint studs. There are even some REALLY nice homozygous paint studs. You may have to ship semen from them, but they exist. Â For those that think color doesn't matter then why not try for the color of the breed of horse you own? Â If you don't get it, nothing lost. Â Â
So is quarter horse just a "type" because they allow TB into the breed and that hors can earn full papers?
Im not saying there are no nice homozygous studs im not at all saying that. I was just saying the first priority on the pick a stud list should not be color. If a hetero stud is the ideal match for a preformance prospect, ill take my chances on having a solid foal. For me personaly, thats just my opinion :-)
| |
| | |
  Champ
Posts: 19623
       Location: Peg-Leg Julia Grimm | You can call AQHA horses anything you want. It doesn't change what they are in the least. Neither does it change the fact that Paints are a color registry. Just like Buckskin and palomino are colors. | |
| | |
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 316
  
| I've been told that you can have a DECENT stud but that same horse would be a GREAT gelding. Many people geld (besides for trying not to flood the market) to give these horses a chance in the barrel pen. Many have way too many hormones racing through their minds to be doing anything besides breeding. Good luck, but my opinion would be to geld unless you just want a foal each year for yourself and don't plan on selling them/not breeding outside horses. | |
| |
| |