I am horrible at saddle fitting. I have a wide (7 inch) triple creek and a 8 inch gullet crown c? which one seems to fit my mare better or do I need to start over from scratch? 

right now to me both look pretty good. BUT I would suggest riding in both and seeing what the sweat marks are like. Saddle fit is mainly to do with the saddle but the pad also plays a part. It could be too thick. The sweat marks will give you a better look to see if the saddle is evenly dispering weight. 

It is hard to tell but the triple creek looks like its sitting lower than I prefer on her wither which generally means its too wide but it has the narrower gullet than the other so..... i am pointing it out as an observation lol. maybe its just the photo.

Is the rough out saddle your crown c? I think that one fits the best...the other one looks like it pops up a bit in the back end. 

The Crown C is a better fit. I dont like the way the Triple Creek is sitting. 

I feel like the Crown C is a good fit, but I also feel it's a tad far forward.  

There aren't pics from the rear of the TC, but It looks to be raised in the back, which isn't good.  

Thank you everyone! 

Hmm, I'm the odd man out b/c I would pick the Triple Creek over the Martin. Not bad, but I feel like the Martin looks very slightly perched because the bar angle appears to be just a bit too narrow - not by much though. I do agree that the Triple Creek is a bit wide, but I would choose a wide saddle over a narrow saddle. Yes the triple creek is sitting a little downhill because it is a bit wide - not too bad, but a little.

I agree to ride in them both, see how they feel, see how they do padded up, and see what the sweat marks looks like and/or which one your horse moves better with.